Cincinnati’s 4-0 start has changed the tone around Scott Satterfield’s team, but the formula behind it is pretty clear: the Bearcats are winning up front, running the ball with force and creating turnovers on defense.
That’s the read from Keegan Nickoson of Bearcat Journal, who pointed to the offensive line, the ground game and takeaways as the three biggest reasons Cincinnati has opened the year unbeaten for the first time since the 2021 season. The Bearcats are coming off a 31-26 home win over Kansas State and now head into a matchup with Arizona carrying real momentum.
Nickoson said Cincinnati’s rushing attack has been a major driver, with the Bearcats ranking No. 12 nationally in rushing yards per game and third in the Big 12 behind BYU and West Virginia. He highlighted a line led by three future draft picks - center Taran Tyo, left guard Evan Tengesdahl and left tackle Joe Cotton - and said the backfield tandem of Cole Tabb and Gi’Bran Payne has pushed the run game from solid to dangerous.
“The Bearcats were always expected to have a good running game, but the two-headed monster of Cole Tabb and Gi’Bran Payne has emerged at running back and taken them from good to great; and they are two to three more great rushing games away from being elite.”
Tabb, in particular, has stood out. Nickoson said he came into fall camp as the No. 3 or 4 back in the room, then kept flashing every time he got the ball.
He cited Tabb’s 11.1 yards per rush mark and described his vision as the kind that can turn a modest gain into a long touchdown. Payne, meanwhile, has added another layer after being buried at Notre Dame behind two first-round picks.
On the defensive side, Cincinnati’s switch to Nate Woody’s 3-4 scheme has helped produce more takeaways, even if the pass rush hasn’t been as consistent over the last two games. Antwan Peek Jr. has been especially disruptive with three forced fumbles in four games.
“Antwan Peek Jr. is the player who can impact the game most easily, as he has three forced fumbles this season.”
Nickoson also singled out linebacker Jonathan Thompson, calling him the Bearcats’ best interior blitzer in 5-6 years, and said cornerback Kenny Worthy has been solid despite a couple of pass interference penalties. Jacob Finley has also held up well at corner.
At quarterback, JC French IV has settled in as a steady fit for what Satterfield wants the offense to be. Nickoson described him as good, not great, but efficient and careful with the ball.
He said French is accurate on play-action shots, can extend plays with his legs and gives Cincinnati enough mobility in the zone read game. The concern, though, is that French hasn’t consistently worked through multiple reads.
“French has been good, not great. He’s perfect for what Scott Satterfield wants the offense to be, and he was also much cheaper than their other QB portal candidates like Lincoln Keinholz and Ethan Grunkemeyer.”
That matters against Arizona because if the Wildcats can take away JV Gibson and force French off his first read, Cincinnati’s passing game could stall.
Nickoson’s assessment of Satterfield’s tenure was blunt. He called it “overall negative,” while also giving some context for the 3-9 season in 2023 and the 5-7 finish in 2024.
He noted the Bearcats had a rough stretch after losing key pieces from the previous era, then pointed to the team’s current position as a chance for Satterfield to stabilize things. Still, he made clear that more is needed.
“He deserves props for starting 4-0 with one of the cheapest rosters in P4 football, but he has to beat Iowa State and Colorado and reach six wins.”
As for Saturday night, Nickoson thinks Arizona can make the final play that decides it. He said Cincinnati has struggled in games kicking off after 10 p.m. ET, and while he expects the Bearcats to run the ball effectively, he believes Arizona’s defense can force French into a late mistake.
“Arizona 31, Cincinnati 24.”
In Other News...
Former Wildcats Made Serious NFL Noise In Week 3
Former Arizona Wildcats made their presence felt across the NFL in Week 3, with several alums turning in performances that stood out for different reasons. Tyler Loop delivered the kind of kicking moment every college program loves to claim a share of, while Genesis Smith helped the Chargers with a pair of interceptions, and veteran Nick Folk added another notable line to a long pro career as the Falcons picked up a win.
Loops latest Sunday spotlight only adds to the sense that Arizonas pipeline is still producing players who can shape games at the highest level. Smiths takeaway haul was especially eye-catching, and Folks climb on the all-time field goals list gave the week a little extra weight for former Wildcats fans tracking familiar names. There were other contributions from ex-Arizona players as well, but the biggest question now is how much of this momentum carries into Week 4. [Read more 🡒]
Arizonas Title Hopes Rest On One Big Rebuilt Roster Question
Arizona is heading into the new season with a very different look after making its first Final Four in 25 years, and that alone has changed the conversation around what this roster can become. Only two key players are back from last season, so the Wildcats have leaned heavily on transfers, freshmen and international additions as they try to turn a rebuilt group into another contender. The recent Red-Blue Showcase offered at least a glimpse of the talent pool, and there was enough there to suggest the pieces are interesting, even if they are still sorting out how they fit.
The biggest question now is how quickly those pieces can settle into defined roles, especially with so many moving parts still in the picture. Arizona is waiting on clarity around the eligibility situation involving RJ Godfrey, while the offensive workload for Ivan Kharchenkov and freshman Caleb Holt remains a key part of the puzzle. For a team with real title hopes, the difference between being a dangerous early-season story and a legitimate March threat may come down to how soon this rebuilt roster starts answering those questions. [Read more 🡒]
Arizona May Have Found Another Young Weapon On Offense
Arizonas offense keeps finding ways to widen its base, and Caleb Smith provided another reminder in the win over Washington State. The freshman receiver was all over the field, finishing with 122 all-purpose yards while adding 86 receiving yards, his first career touchdown catch and a 36-yard punt return. For a Wildcats attack that has leaned on young playmakers at different points, Smiths versatility stood out as a real plus.
Smiths best work came in the middle of the games biggest sequence, when Arizona needed someone to help push a drive forward and flip momentum. He delivered with key receptions and a spark in the return game, giving the Wildcats another option to build around as the season moves on. The question now is how much more of that growing role Arizona can keep unlocking. [Read more 🡒]