Arizona has done everything you’d normally need to do to crack the AP Top 25 - win games, win them convincingly, and beat the kind of opponents that make a resume look real. Still, the Wildcats are on the outside looking in.
Brent Brennan’s team moved to 5-1 after rolling past West Virginia 52-31, and that victory pushed Arizona to the edge of the rankings rather than into them. The Wildcats checked in with 82 votes, which left them 28th overall and just behind Wisconsin and Oregon among teams outside the top 25.
It’s a strange spot for a team that has been as steady as Arizona has been since its lone loss. The Wildcats went 3-0 in non-conference play and are now 2-1 in Big 12 action. They blasted Cincinnati 34-7 at home the week before their win over West Virginia on the road, and the only blemish on the record came against BYU, a top-10 team that Arizona actually led 17-14 at halftime.
That BYU game still stands as the Wildcats’ only defeat, and it came against a legitimate CFP contender. The Cougars also got Arizona’s closest home game of the season.
Even so, the AP voters haven’t been sold. Arizona is the only Big 12 team in the receiving-votes category, while BYU is No. 8, Texas Tech is 10th, Utah 11th, Oklahoma State 18th and Houston 20th.
The Wildcats’ resume also compares favorably to a couple of the teams sitting at the bottom of the poll. No.
24 SMU is 4-1, with two power-conference wins - a three-point road win at Florida State and a nine-point home win over Boston College - and its loss came at Louisville, a team that is 3-3 and not drawing any AP votes. No.
23 Boise State is 5-1, but its only defeat was against Oregon, which was ranked in the top five at the time and is now out of the poll after losing to UCLA. Boise State’s best win is at home over Memphis, and the Broncos also had to survive a close road game at Fresno State last week.
Arizona won’t have a chance to change the conversation immediately. The Wildcats are off this week, but they could make a stronger push into the top 25 when they host Iowa State at Casino Del Sol Stadium on Oct.
- The time and TV information for that game will be announced later.