The Big 12’s new rule has turned Moe Odum’s path back to Arizona State into a case study in how messy college sports has become.
Odum had already run out of NCAA eligibility when he signed with KB Trepça, a professional basketball club in Kosovo. He had completed four college seasons, and the Big 12 had not yet put its ban on former professionals in place. A judge later gave him temporary eligibility for a fifth season, but the conference rule still blocked him from returning to the Sun Devils, even though he never played a minute for Trepça.
That tension sits at the center of the debate: whether fairness means protecting a player’s chance to keep his college career alive or protecting the roster spot of the athlete brought in to replace him.
Victoria Jackson, an ASU sports historian and professor of history, said shutting out players in Odum’s position runs against what universities are supposed to do.
“It’s ruthless and heartless to say we won’t welcome you back,” Jackson said of athletes who signed but never played for their professional team.
Don Gibson, associate dean and executive director of ASU Law’s Bud Selig Sports Law and Business program, sees it differently. He said the line between college and pro sports has to mean something.
“You either play college sports or you play professional sports,” Gibson said.
The Big 12 approved its policy unanimously on Aug. 26, more than a month after Trepça announced Odum’s signing. It applies to every conference-sponsored sport and stands on its own, separate from whatever the NCAA decides about eligibility.
The conference said: “No member institution may roster an athlete who has, at any time … Signed a contract with any Professional Sports League to provide athletics services,”
The policy also covers athletes who declared for a pro draft and didn’t withdraw in time, along with those listed on a professional roster. Its scope goes beyond the basketball-focused rules adopted by the ACC, SEC and Big Ten, which specifically mention the NBA, G League and WNBA.
ASU Athletics Director Graham Rossini told Arizona Sports that Odum’s professional contract kept him from coming back under the Big 12 rule. Odum then entered the transfer portal, opening the door to other college programs.
On Tuesday, San José State announced it had signed Odum for the 2026-27 season.
For Jackson, the fact that another school stepped in doesn’t erase the academic fallout that can come with a forced move.
“It has the potential to hurt the academic progress of an athlete if they’re not able to pick up where they left off at their previous institution, because not all credits transfer,” Jackson said.
She also pushed back on the idea that schools should prioritize new recruits over athletes already on campus.
“If they still have eligibility, you hold a responsibility to them both athletically and academically,” Jackson said.
Gibson argued that once a player signs to compete professionally, that player has made a choice that comes with consequences. If a return to college becomes the goal later, he said, that athlete has to understand the school may have already moved on.
“If you signed that contract, you had a clear intention of wanting to play at that level, and if you make that choice, you have to suffer those consequences,” Gibson said.
He did leave room for exceptions, though. After learning that Odum had no eligibility left when he signed, Gibson said new facts or unusual circumstances could justify a return.
Jackson said the growing presence of paid college athletes only makes the boundary between amateur and professional sports harder to defend. Gibson disagreed, saying college sports still differ because athletes are also students working toward degrees.
The issue gets even more complicated with international players. ASU center Filip Malesevic came to the program after six seasons with Serbia’s KK Dynamic and KMP Beograd.
ESPN reported that the Big 12 built in provisions meant to allow international players with professional experience to compete. But the conference’s announcement does not clearly spell out an exception for those athletes or distinguish between pro experience before college and pro experience after.
Gibson said overseas club systems offer development that American athletes usually get through school sports.
Aaron Hernandez, director of the National Sports Law Institute and a professor of practice at Marquette University Law School, said a blanket waiver could explain how international players are being treated.
Malesevic entered college after playing professionally, while Odum tried to return after signing once his college eligibility had expired.
Hernandez said the NCAA’s June eligibility ruling did not change the Big 12’s separate restriction on Odum’s return to ASU. He added that while Odum could have challenged the rule in court, a conference waiver would have been the more relevant path because Odum still had another college option outside the Big 12.
“It’d be hard to challenge this rule in court because he’s got other options,” Hernandez said.
A waiver request, Hernandez said, would have forced the Big 12 to look closely at why Odum signed in the first place and decide whether that situation deserved an exception.
“This kid thought it was done,” Hernandez said. “Then it wasn’t.”
In Other News...
Arizona State Suddenly Faces A 2027 Schedule Problem Fans Will Notice
Arizona States non-conference calendar for the coming years just got a little shakier, and fans who like seeing the Sun Devils line up against regional opponents may notice the ripple effect quickly. UNLV head coach Dan Mullen confirmed that the Rebels will not host Arizona State in their non-conference home game next season, with Colorado State stepping into that slot instead.
The change is part of a wider scheduling shuffle across college football, driven by the SECs move to a nine-game conference schedule and the expanded College Football Playoff format. For Arizona State, it is another reminder that even games already penciled in can be vulnerable when the broader sport keeps rearranging itself. [Read more 🡒]
ASU Faces A Telling Final Test Before Oklahoma State Arrives
A lightning-shortened practice was hardly the ideal way for Arizona State to prepare, but it did give Kenny Dillingham another chance to stress how much sharper his team needs to be with No. 25 Oklahoma State coming to town. The Sun Devils have spent the week trying to clean up both sides of the ball, and the matchup offers a clear measuring stick against a Cowboys team that can force turnovers and turn them into points in a hurry.
Dillinghams focus has been less on the weather interruption and more on the bigger challenge ahead, because Oklahoma State brings the kind of balance that exposes mistakes fast. For ASU, this is the sort of late-season test that can reveal whether the offense and defense are truly moving in the right direction, or whether there is still more work to do before the stakes get even higher. [Read more 🡒]
Reed Harris Is Giving Arizona State A Breakout Fans Can't Ignore
Reed Harris has gone from promising piece to one of the most compelling wideouts in the country, and Arizona State is seeing the payoff every week. The Sun Devils receiver was named a semifinalist for the 2026 Biletnikoff Award, a sign that his production has pushed him into the national conversation while he ranks ninth nationally in receiving yards.
Harris has already topped his previous seasons totals in catches, yards and touchdowns, which helps explain why his rise has started to attract attention beyond Tempe. A recent NFL mock draft even pegged him as a potential 2027 pick, adding another layer to what has become a breakout stretch for a player Arizona State can no longer keep under the radar. [Read more 🡒]
