Ketel Marte sits at the center of two very different futures for the Diamondbacks. One path points to a rebound at the plate, steady enough defense to keep him valuable, and a season that looks much closer to his 2025 version. The other is the one that comes for almost every hitter in his 30s: a gradual slide, made sharper by age and injury.
The optimistic case starts with the offense. Marte’s bat speed dipped from the 85th percentile to the 82nd percentile this season, and his hard-hit rate slipped from the 73rd percentile to the 64th percentile.
But those numbers still sit comfortably above league average. He also showed enough life in stretches to suggest there’s still another good offensive season in him.
In May and June, he posted slugging percentages of .524 and .558, both better than league average. That matters because it suggests the ceiling is still there, even if it showed up in bursts.
BABIP offers another reason to think a bounce is possible. Over his Diamondbacks seasons, Marte’s BABIP was above average only twice, in 2019 and 2021.
That means much of his production over the years has come without the benefit of unusually good luck on balls in play. If that turns in his favor, the offensive line could move up quickly.
Pitch mix also tells part of the story. In 2026, Marte saw 3.2% more changeups and 3.9% fewer sliders.
The slugging drop against sliders was minor and could just be noise. The changeup split was much more striking: his slugging against that pitch fell from .542 to .290.
If he starts handling changeups the way he did in 2025 again, that could be a major driver of a stronger season.
That idea lines up with his Batting Run Value as well. Baseball Savant pegged him at 4 in 2026, basically average. A return that lands roughly two-thirds of the way back toward his 2025 level would put him at 22 in 2027.
Defensively, there are both warning signs and reasons for caution, but not panic. His range dropped to a career low of negative 5 in The Fielding Bible, which fits the aging pattern.
Still, the overall defensive results were solid. He finished with 2 DRS and 4 OAA, and Baseball Savant gave him a Fielding Run Value of 5, which landed in the 78th percentile.
That suggests he may not have his old range, but he can still be a plus at second base if the decline stops there.
There is also a small baserunning wrinkle. Marte could cut back on stealing to lessen the risk of a hamstring issue coming back, while still taking extra bases when they’re there. That would probably push his Baserunning Run Value from 1 in 2026 to 0 in 2027, but it could also help him stay on the field more often.
The colder case is built on age and comps, and it is harder to dismiss. Marte is under contract for four more seasons, with a player option for a fifth, so the Diamondbacks are looking well beyond one year.
Using Baseball Reference’s “most similar batters at through [age] 32,” the three closest matches going into their age-32 seasons averaged 2.6 WAR at that point, almost identical to Marte’s 2.5 WAR at age 32. But over the next four seasons, those same players averaged just 0.725 WAR.
That is a steep drop from what Marte produced in 2026.
He was 33 years old on October 12, already past the peak years and deeper into the decline phase of the aging curve. The quote from Roark in October 2021 puts it plainly: “A typical player peaks around age 26 and gradually declines afterward in what we know as the age curve. For those fortunate enough to stick around into their late 30s. that decline becomes quite sharp.”
Injuries only make that picture murkier. Marte dealt with knee and hamstring problems last season, and those kinds of issues can linger.
If they do, they could drag down both his offense and his availability. His range could also keep sliding if 2026 was not the bottom.
The one built-in safety valve is positional flexibility: if the defense keeps slipping, he could move to designated hitter to preserve the bat.
So the choice with Marte is pretty clear. There is a credible case for a bounce back, powered by better luck, better results against changeups, and enough defensive value to remain an asset. But there is just as real a case that age, injury, and the aging curve win out, and that the decline gets harder to ignore over the next few seasons.
In Other News...
Diamondbacks Suddenly Have A Bullpen Depth Problem To Solve
Arizonas bullpen has been in constant flux all season, and Derek Laws exit only adds another layer to a group that already had to absorb multiple injuries along the way. The veteran right-hander signed a minor league deal in January while rehabbing from flexor tendon surgery, finally made his Diamondbacks debut in late August, and then found himself off the 40-man roster after a late-season designation for assignment.
Law is now a free agent after clearing waivers and being outrighted to Triple-A, leaving the club with another arm to replace heading into the offseason. Arizona will need to sort through a deeper relief-market puzzle, too, with several other key bullpen pieces also eligible to test free agency, including Kevin Ginkel, Taylor Clarke, Jonathan Loaisiga and Ryan Thompson. [Read more 🡒]
Diamondbacks Enter A Difficult Winter With One Pressure Point Clear
The Diamondbacks spent another season right on the edge of the postseason and came up short again, a frustrating finish for a club that still posted a strong record. Now the front office heads into the winter with the same broad challenge it has faced before: keeping the roster competitive while juggling guaranteed contracts and a wave of impending free agents, especially on the pitching side.
There is at least some clarity at the top, with Torey Lovullo back on a two-year deal and general manager Mike Hazen already under contract through 2028. The more immediate question is how Arizona will rework the staff around them, and the pitching department appears to be where the first change is coming into focus as the organization resets for another run. [Read more 🡒]
D-Backs Could Regret Letting This Bullpen Breakout Get Away
A bullpen that spent much of the season fighting uphill can ill afford to let reliable arms slip through the cracks, and Jonathan Loaisiga is the kind of reliever who tends to look even more valuable once winter shopping begins. The right-hander spent 2026 in Arizonas bullpen and gave the Diamondbacks exactly the sort of steady presence teams spend all offseason trying to find, which is why his name is already circulating as a potential fit elsewhere.
For a club trying to navigate a shaky late-inning picture, the temptation to chase a proven arm is obvious. Loaisiga is now on the open market after his time in Arizona, and with the market for relief pitching always moving quickly, the Diamondbacks could wind up watching one of their more useful bullpen answers land in a place that needs him as much as they do. [Read more 🡒]