The Arizona Diamondbacks survived Tuesday night in Pittsburgh, but the 8-7 extra-inning win did not quiet the biggest question hanging over the club: what to do with Paul Sewald in the ninth inning.
Arizona had the game under control for most of the night. The Diamondbacks carried a 6-0 lead into the bottom of the eighth, only for right-hander Ryan Thompson to run into trouble and let the Pirates trim the margin to 6-3 before the ninth. That turned what looked like a routine finish into a save chance for Sewald, and it unraveled fast.
Pittsburgh answered with a two-run homer and then a solo shot to tie the game, handing Sewald his third blown save of the season. He got one out before being removed, and Arizona had to regroup in extra innings to escape with the win.
The outing pushed Sewald’s ERA to 5.26, and his recent stretch has been even rougher. Over his last six games, that number sits at 11.57. Even with saves still coming at times this season, the overall picture has become hard to ignore.
For a pitcher whose job is to slam the door, numbers like that are going to keep the conversation alive. Tuesday’s collapse only sharpened the concern that this may not be a one-off problem.
After the game, Torey Lovullo said the Diamondbacks will keep leaning on Sewald to get those “big outs” and to hand him the ball. But when asked whether Sewald would get the next save chance, Lovullo stopped short of giving a direct answer.
“I haven’t thought anything about tomorrow,” he said, according to SI’s Jack Sommers. “I’ve got to get through right now, but if there is something that will happen, I’ll make sure that I talk to the right people first.”
That leaves Arizona in a familiar spot: still trusting Sewald, but not quite locking him into the role without hesitation. The Diamondbacks clearly value him in the bullpen, yet Lovullo’s answer made it clear the club is at least leaving itself room to reconsider if the late-inning issues keep piling up.
With the postseason race tightening, those decisions only get heavier from here.
In Other News...
Diamondbacks May Finally Have A Real First Base Answer
The first-base picture in Arizona had been a headache for much of the season, with the position lagging offensively through mid-July and forcing the club to keep cycling through options. Since Pavin Smith was designated for assignment, the conversation has narrowed to Ildemaro Vargas, Tim Tawa and Tyler Locklear, a trio that gives the Diamondbacks at least a more workable set of choices than the revolving door they were dealing with earlier.
Vargas has stood out as the steadiest glove in the group, and that matters for a team trying to get more certainty out of a spot that has been anything but settled. The encouraging part is that the bats have also looked better since July 10, which gives Arizona a chance to build something more stable there if it can sort out how to balance defense, handedness and the rest of the lineup moving forward. [Read more 🡒]
Diamondbacks May Have Quietly Avoided A Trade Deadline Gut Punch
The Red Soxs decision to send Connelly Early to Washington instead of Arizona may end up looking like a small but meaningful break for the Diamondbacks. Reports indicate Boston turned away Arizonas interest in the left-hander and ultimately preferred Curtis Mead in the deal, a sign the Red Sox wanted a more established return than whatever package was on the table from Phoenix.
For Arizona, the bigger takeaway may be what it did not have to surrender in a deadline chase. Ryan Waldschmidt, the young bat who could have been the kind of prospect Boston covets in a deal like this, was not part of the public discussion, and that alone hints at how close the Diamondbacks may have come to a painful price tag. Whether they were ever truly in position to land Early is still the part left hanging. [Read more 🡒]
Diamondbacks May Need To Take A Real Look At This Infielder
Arizonas infield depth chart has a way of turning up names that were easy to overlook a year ago, and this one fits that mold. The Diamondbacks pulled Danny Serretti from the Tigers in the AAA phase of the 2025 Rule 5 draft, a low-key move that barely registered at the time. After a rough run in Detroits farm system, he has looked far more comfortable in Arizonas minor league affiliates this season, showing a better feel at the plate and a more disciplined approach that has put him back on the radar.
What makes Serretti worth tracking now is that the offensive gains have come alongside a clearer defensive lane. He has mostly settled in at second base since joining the organization, giving the Diamondbacks a look at a player who is no longer trying to do too much or cover too much ground. For a club that always has to balance immediate roster needs with the next wave of depth, that kind of quiet development can matter, especially if the bat continues to trend in the right direction. [Read more 🡒]