The Utah Mammoth went into 2025 thinking they might have landed a difference-maker in JJ Peterka, a 23-year-old they believed could grow into a star. Instead, the move turned into a lot less than they hoped, and it may have left them wondering what this roster would have looked like if the gamble had paid off.
Utah gave up two young players for Peterka, and the biggest sting came from Josh Doan. Doan, who is the same age at 24, put together 27 goals and 50 points.
Peterka, meanwhile, finished with 25 goals and 47 points. That gap matters because the Mammoth expected more from a player who had already shown real production with the Buffalo Sabres.
Peterka’s 2024-25 season in Buffalo was the kind of year that made Utah believe it was getting something bigger. He scored 27 goals and piled up 68 points, and the Mammoth were hoping that level of offense would carry over and keep climbing. Utah needed scoring, and Peterka looked like a player who could deliver it before even turning 24.
Instead, the fit never fully clicked. The Mammoth eventually moved Peterka’s contract to the Boston Bruins for two first-round picks.
They also sent Michael Kesselring in the deal, though he only played 34 games. Utah no longer has to pay 7.7 million for a player who didn’t do too much, and the team still made the postseason.
One of the picks from Boston was then used to bring in a much-needed goalie.
That leaves Utah in a different place now, focused on getting quality starts from its new backup rather than dwelling on what Peterka might have become. The upside was obvious: Peterka could have been a 30-plus goal scorer and maybe even a 70-plus point player in a season. If that version had shown up, the Mammoth might have had another superstar on their hands.
Boston, for its part, still has a chance to get real value out of Peterka. The Bruins need scoring, and Peterka is only 24, so there’s still time for him to put it all together.
But for Utah, the trade never became the offensive boost it was supposed to be. It could have been much more.
In Other News...
Mammoth Prospects Just Earned The Kind Of Buzz Fans Crave
Scott Wheelers mid-July ranking of the top 100 NHL prospects offered a useful snapshot of where the Utah Mammoths pipeline stands, and it was a strong one. Five players tied to the organization made the list, with Tij Iginla leading the way at No. 7, followed by Caleb Desnoyers at No. 22, Ethan Belchetz at No. 30, Dmitri Simashev at No. 41 and Daniil But at No. 77. For a franchise still shaping its long-term identity, that kind of spread across the prospect board is exactly the sort of attention that can make a rebuild feel a little more real.
The appeal here is not just volume, but variety. Iginla gives the group a high-end headline name, Desnoyers adds another premium piece near the top of the class, and Simashev already has 28 NHL games on his resume, which gives him a different kind of credibility than a pure lottery-ticket prospect. Belchetz and But round out the picture with more developmental intrigue, and together they give Utah a future roster conversation that feels deeper than one or two blue-chip names. The next question is how many of these prospects can turn buzz into actual NHL impact, and how quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Coyotes Fans Can Finally Dream Bigger On Logan Cooley
Logan Cooleys season had the kind of jolt that can slow a young player down, but it didnt really change the direction he was headed. Before the injury interruption, he had given Arizona a glimpse of a forward whose game was starting to tilt toward something bigger, and even after missing nearly two months, he still finished with 24 goals and 19 assists in 54 games. For a player still early in his career, that kind of production only adds to the sense that the Coyotes may already have a legitimate centerpiece taking shape.
The more interesting part for Arizona is what comes next if Cooley keeps climbing at the same pace and stays on the ice. His goal-scoring rate has risen steadily, and the projections now point to a player who could be in the 40-goal neighborhood by 2026-27 if development and health line up. For a franchise looking for reasons to think bigger, that is the sort of trajectory that changes the conversation from promise to expectation. [Read more 🡒]