The Utah Mammoth have a decision on their hands, but the cleanest move might be the simplest one: don’t match the New Jersey Devils’ offer sheet for Barrett Hayton.
New Jersey went after Hayton on Wednesday, July 1, with a one-year deal worth $4.775 million. Offer sheets are rare enough in the NHL that they always grab attention, but this one doesn’t look like the kind Utah needs to chase.
The price isn’t outrageous. The fit is the issue.
Utah already added Vincent Trocheck, and that changes the picture at center. With Logan Cooley and Nick Schmaltz also in the mix, the Mammoth have enough down the middle without locking themselves into Hayton for another season. If they matched the offer, they’d also be stuck with him for a full year before being able to move him, which means a real risk of losing him for nothing.
That’s part of what makes this such a tricky call, even if the contract itself is manageable. Hayton, now 26, has not delivered the kind of jump Utah had hoped for.
He followed a career-best 2024-25 season with a much quieter one in 2025-25, finishing with 10 goals and 15 assists. The year before, he posted 20 goals and 26 assists.
That drop-off matters.
There’s still a version of Hayton who could help an offense next season. The problem is that the breakout Utah has been waiting for keeps getting harder to bank on. At this point in his career, the clock is ticking on that kind of leap.
And with the Mammoth’s top nine already looking effective and solid, there isn’t a strong reason to spend the money just to keep him. If Utah lets him go, it would receive a 2027 second-round pick.
The bigger question is whether the team would ever trade Hayton for that return on its own. Probably not.
But that doesn’t mean it should take the gamble and keep him, either.
In Other News...
Ducks Suddenly Face The Young Core Crisis Fans Feared
Anaheims young-core picture changed fast during the first round of the 2026 NHL draft, and not in the tidy, patient way rebuilding teams usually hope for. The Ducks already had to absorb the shock of moving Mason McTavish, a move that signaled just how aggressively the organization is willing to reshape its future, and now the front office is staring at another major decision involving the next wave of talent.
Leo Carlssons situation puts the Ducks in a familiar but uncomfortable spot: keep a franchise center in place and keep building around him, or let the market set the terms and collect a hefty draft return. Either way, the cap math is getting tighter, and the ripple effects could reach Cutter Gauthier as well, leaving Anaheim to sort out whether it can realistically hold on to both of its most important young pieces without compromising the rest of the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Former Coyotes Defenseman Suddenly Framed As A Major Blue Line Fix
The Rangers have spent the summer trying to patch up a blue line that needed more stability behind Adam Fox and Vladislav Gavrikov, and the front office has responded with a pair of moves aimed squarely at the second pairing. Sean Durzi and Marcus Pettersson are the latest additions, giving New York a different look on defense as it tries to rebound from last season and build a back end that can hold up over a full year.
Durzi arrives with some offensive touch and Pettersson brings a more steady, stay-at-home profile, which gives the Rangers options they did not have before. The bigger question now is how the pieces fit together, especially since one of those additions came as part of the Vincent Trocheck deal and the other came via a separate trade, leaving the team with a reshaped defense and a few decisions still to sort out before opening night. [Read more 🡒]
Roadrunners Add Another Crease Question Fans Will Want To Track
The Tucson Roadrunners have added another name to the mix in goal, bringing in Jesper Vikman on an AHL contract as they continue sorting out the crease picture for the season ahead. Vikman has spent the past few years moving between the AHL and ECHL, and his path to Tucson has included junior hockey with the Vancouver Giants in the WHL before turning pro.
For Roadrunners fans, the move is less about one signing than about how the goaltending depth chart might settle over time. Vikman was originally drafted by the Vegas Golden Knights in 2020, and his experience in multiple pro leagues gives Tucson another option to monitor as the affiliate of the Utah Mammoth keeps building out its roster. [Read more 🡒]