The Utah Mammoth came into the season looking like a team ready to push for the Western Conference playoffs. They spent the offseason making real noise, adding MacKenzie Weegar, Anders Lee, Vincent Trocheck, and young goalie Sebastian Cossa, who arrived from the Detroit Red Wings in a summer trade.
That move left Utah with a Cossa-Karel Vejmelka tandem the club believed in. A quarter of the way through the year, that confidence is getting tested.
The bigger picture still looks decent. Utah has controlled roughly 57% of the expected goals at five-on-five, which ranks second in the NHL, and it is giving up just 2.15 expected goals against per 60 minutes.
Those are strong team numbers. The problem is that the Mammoth have still been outscored at five-on-five, and the reason is hard to miss: the goaltending has not held up.
Vejmelka has taken the biggest step backward. Last season, he was a workhorse, appearing in 64 games and putting up an .897 SV%, a 2.75 GAA, and 6.9 goals saved above expected, per MoneyPuck. This year, those numbers have fallen off sharply to an .872 SV%, a 3.14 GAA, and -7.0 goals saved above expected.
Cossa’s numbers have been rough, too. In eight games, the 23-year-old has posted an .863 SV% and a 3.56 GAA.
He had only one NHL game under his belt before this season, so it’s not fair to lay everything at his feet. Still, that kind of inexperience does not make life easier for Utah, especially after the team sent a 2026 first-round pick to Detroit for him in June.
There are some caveats here. Utah’s defense could be better, and some players have said as much in interviews.
But the Mammoth also allow the fifth-fewest shots per game in the NHL, so they are at least doing a decent job of limiting volume. That makes the goaltending numbers stand out even more.
It’s not the only issue on the roster, either. Utah has also been hit by injuries to Logan Cooley, Nick Schmaltz, and Dylan Guenther.
And the penalty kill has been a mess, operating at 69.33%, well below the league average of 77.69%. Some of that can be tied back to the goaltending, but it’s still another problem the team has to sort through.
For now, a major move feels unlikely. Vejmelka has been an NHL goalie for a long time, and Utah seems more likely to give him a chance to straighten things out. The club could eventually look for a third goalie to put pressure on Cossa and Vejmelka, but that feels more like a move for the new year than something coming right away.
That said, this can’t drag on forever. Goaltending is volatile, especially with a young player in the mix, but Utah has invested too much in this group to sit around indefinitely. The Mammoth need at least league-average work in net, and they are not getting it.
If Utah decides to explore the trade market, it has the assets to make a serious move. The organization has a top-five prospect system in the NHL and owns its full set of picks over the next four NHL Entry Drafts, plus a few extras, including a 2028 conditional first-round pick from the Florida Panthers that came through the Boston Bruins in the JJ Peterka deal.
The names that come up are Sam Montembeault of the Montreal Canadiens, John Gibson of the Detroit Red Wings, and Jordan Binnington of the St. Louis Blues.
None of them looks like a clean fix. Montembeault has not played this season because of an injury and, even when healthy, is likely Montreal’s number three goalie.
Gibson has struggled badly in Detroit, carrying a goals-saved above expected of -7.6 in 13 games. Binnington has been even worse by that metric, sitting at -8.2 goals in six games, with Kevin Lankinen also below him in Vancouver.
There is one more name in the mix: Matt Murray, a free agent who played decently in a handful of games with the Seattle Kraken last season. He has injury concerns of his own, but the market is thin enough that he would at least be an option if Utah wants to go hunting.
For now, the safest play may be patience. The Mammoth are waiting to see whether Cossa and Vejmelka can settle in, and the answer to that question may determine whether Utah sticks with what it has or goes looking for a fix.
In Other News...
Utah Just Unveiled A Winter Classic Look Fans Will Debate
The Winter Classic jersey reveal always brings out strong opinions, and Utahs latest look did exactly that when the Mammoth and Avalanche unveiled their sweaters on Nov. 18. Utahs design drew plenty of positive attention online, with the team leaning into the history behind the jersey and giving fans something to dissect well before the outdoor game arrives.
For Coyotes fans watching another division rival step into a national showcase, the interesting part is how much buzz the unveiling created before a puck has even dropped. The conversation around the jersey has already taken on a life of its own, and with the Winter Classic still ahead, the look is set to keep getting scrutinized as the event at the Utah Utes football stadium draws closer. [Read more 🡒]
Utahs Goalie Problem Could Push Bill Armstrong Toward A Low-Risk Fix
Utahs goaltending has become one of the clearest pressure points in the early part of the season, with the Mammoth sitting 23rd in the NHL in goals against per game. General manager Bill Armstrong has already been tied to trade chatter around elite names such as Connor Hellebuyck, but the bigger question may be whether Utah wants to chase a splash or look for a steadier, lower-cost answer in net.
Pierre LeBrun reported that Armstrong has been exploring the market with an eye on goaltending help, and that kind of search makes sense with Karel Vejmelka and Sebastian Cossa both underperforming. One option that has surfaced is Montreals Sam Montembeault, whose recent track record has been uneven, but whose availability is complicated by the fact he has yet to play this season after getting hurt in practice. [Read more 🡒]
Mammoth Just Gave Fans A Real Goalie Debate
The Utah Mammoth finally snapped a six-game losing streak with a 4-1 win over the Colorado Avalanche, and the kind of night that can change a conversation in a hurry. The offense got contributions from Liam O'Brien, Vincent Trocheck, Dmitri Simashev and Kevin Stenlund, while the game had the edge you would expect from a matchup that turned physical and featured a fight between Gabriel Landeskog and Jack McBain.
Sebastian Cossa was the biggest reason the result held, turning aside 30 of 31 shots and giving the Mammoth the sort of goaltending performance that can make a coaching staff pause. For a team that has been searching for traction, one strong start does not settle anything, but it does add a new layer to the goalie picture and give Utah something to think about as it tries to build on a much-needed win. [Read more 🡒]
