Cardinals Rookie Back Is Giving Fans A Real Draft Debate

Despite initial doubts about the 2023 draft class, a group of standout rookies in New York is beginning to defy expectations and make significant impacts on their teams.

A rookie class that was supposed to be light on fireworks has still managed to leave a mark, and nowhere is that more obvious than in New York. Four of the 10 players worth spotlighting here are based at MetLife Stadium, a reminder that even in a draft class short on broad league-wide impact, a few teams have already found real contributors.

Start with the Jets’ tight end, Sadiq, who has turned a slow spring into a fast start. He missed much of the offseason after hernia surgery, so he entered Frank Reich’s new offense behind schedule.

Then Mason Taylor went down with a thumb injury, and Sadiq was thrust into a central role instead of a supporting one. He answered on Sunday against the Lions with 105 yards and his first NFL receiving touchdown, adding to the rushing score he scored in Week 1.

Through that performance, he moved to eighth among all tight ends with 143 receiving yards, exactly the kind of production New York hoped for when Darren Mougey used one of the Jets’ three first-round picks on him.

The Jets have another rookie making noise on the other side of the ball in Bailey. He had a strong training camp and has carried that momentum into the regular season, posting two sacks and 14 quarterback pressures through three games.

That pressure total is tied for 12th among all NFL players. He’s also piled up eight stops and 12 tackles, showing up as more than just a pass-rush specialist.

That complete-game start has helped New York sit fourth defensively, fourth against the pass and seventh against the run.

New York’s rookie success doesn’t stop there. Reese, a 20-year-old prospect whose position fit was a real question coming into the league, has settled in as an inside linebacker after the team chose that path over edge rusher.

The results have been immediate. He has 18 solo tackles through three games, fourth-most in the NFL and second among linebackers, while playing 98% of the snaps.

His missed tackle rate is just 3.8%, a sharp number for a rookie asked to handle that much responsibility.

The Giants also have a rookie helping keep the operation upright. Mauigoa, who moved inside after playing tackle in college, has started three games and hasn’t allowed a sack.

According to Pro Football Focus, he has given up only two pressures and a pair of quarterback hits. That matters for a team that has been hammered by injuries, including season-enders to quarterback Jaxson Dart and edge rusher Brian Burns, yet still sits at 2-1.

In 2025, the Giants allowed 48 sacks. Through three games with Mauigoa inside, they’ve given up only seven.

Elsewhere, the Cowboys may have found another defensive piece in Barham. Dallas used first-round picks on edge rusher Malachi Lawrence and safety Caleb Downs, but Barham has forced his way into the conversation too.

Through three weeks, he has started at the second level and played 63% of the snaps, putting up 20 tackles with four for loss and a forced fumble. The former Maryland and Michigan standout has been useful against the run, though his coverage is still a work in progress after he allowed six catches on six targets, including a touchdown.

Downs is making his own case as a day-one difference-maker. The former Ohio State All-American leads Dallas with 21 tackles and has also been effective in coverage. He already has a sack, six stops and three quarterback pressures, giving the Cowboys a versatile presence on a defense that ranks 30th in yards allowed and 25th in points allowed.

The Cardinals’ rookie back Love is carrying a heavy load, too. One of just two first-year running backs handling the bulk of his team’s carries, the No. 3 pick has already rushed for 160 yards at 3.9 yards per carry.

His best outing came in Week 3, when he ran 21 times for 90 yards against the 49ers and added five receptions. On pace for 906 rushing yards and 1,156 yards from scrimmage, Love is producing in spite of an underwhelming quarterback situation with Jacoby Brissett.

In Tampa Bay, Trotter has looked like a linebacker built for the modern game. He has played only two games because of a shoulder sprain, but when he’s been on the field, he’s been everywhere: 21 tackles, 10 stops, a pick-six and a sack while logging more than 87% of the snaps.

With Lavonte David retired and the Buccaneers still sorting out their second level, Trotter looks like the long-term answer. The signing of veteran Alex Anzalone helps, but Trotter has already shown he can handle the box, coverage and the pass rush.

Cleveland, meanwhile, appears to have found immediate help at receiver. Boston, a 6-foot-4 wideout taken in the second round, has become the focal point of the Browns’ passing game with nine catches for 195 yards and two touchdowns.

That yardage total ranks 18th among all NFL pass catchers, and he has done it in an offense that ranks 30th in yards and 24th in points scored while working with Deshaun Watson. If this pace holds, Boston would finish with 1,105 yards.

And then there’s Rodriguez in Miami, who has given the Dolphins one of the few bright spots in a 0-3 start. The season has already turned rough with De’Von Achane lost for the year to a torn ACL, but Rodriguez has flashed real long-term promise.

The second-round pick from Texas Tech has 28 tackles, 19 stops and his first career interception, which came in Week 3 off Patrick Mahomes. He’s playing 97.6% of the snaps and already looks like one of the more active middle linebackers in the league.

That’s the bigger picture here: a rookie class that hasn’t produced much across the league, but still has a few players changing the feel of their teams right away. In New York especially, the talent is starting to show up fast.

In Other News...

Cardinals Snap Counts Expose Who Carried The Defense In Costly Loss

The Cardinals defensive workload against San Francisco was spread across a wide cast, with 20 players logging snaps on that side of the ball and the snap totals offering a clear look at who the coaching staff leaned on in a costly loss. The breakdown across the defensive line, linebackers and secondary showed a unit that had to shuffle responsibility throughout the game, while the special teams group was even busier, with 32 players taking part there.

Those snap counts also help explain how much Arizona had to manage around injuries and uneven individual performances as the game wore on. Beyond the defensive rotation, the special teams numbers added another layer to the story, including the kicking and punting work that can swing field position in a tight NFC West matchup, and the full usage chart left plenty to unpack about who held up and who was pushed into a heavier role than expected. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals May Have A Tough QB Decision Around Carson Beck

Arizonas quarterback room is already drawing attention as the Cardinals weigh whether to reshuffle it before the season pushes deeper into view. Jacoby Brissett and Gardner Minshew are both on expiring contracts, and that detail has sparked talk that the front office could explore trades to open up more snaps for rookie Carson Beck, who remains the long-term storyline at the position.

Mike LaFleur has acknowledged the offense has had its struggles, but he stopped short of placing those issues on Brissetts play. That leaves the Cardinals in a familiar spot for a team trying to balance present stability with future plans, and the next move at quarterback could say plenty about how aggressively they want to hand the job over to Beck. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Just Caught A Break Before A Meaningful Giants Test

A difficult road trip to MetLife Stadium just got a little less intimidating for Arizona. New York will be without Brian Burns, its top pass rusher, after surgery revealed a torn ACL that ends his season, and the Giants also will be missing starting quarterback Jaxson Dart for the rest of the regular season because of a knee injury.

For a Cardinals team heading into a meaningful Week 4 matchup, that changes the look of the opponent in a hurry. Burns was the kind of edge presence that can alter protection plans and force offenses to play on edge, while Darts absence removes a key piece of New Yorks offensive approach, leaving Arizona to prepare for a different kind of challenge than it expected when the schedule was released. [Read more 🡒]