One of the boldest ideas floating around the NHL offseason has Edmonton linked to Cutter Gauthier, and it comes from Allan Mitchell’s latest piece for The Athletic. Mitchell starts with Kirill Marchenko in Columbus, then pushes the thought a step further by asking what the odds are of the Oilers making a real run at Gauthier.
At first glance, the fit makes plenty of sense. Gauthier is coming off a 41-goal season, he shoots from just about everywhere, and he has the kind of speed to keep pace with Edmonton’s top-end talent. He checks a lot of boxes for a team that has spent years searching for a winger who can solve more than one problem at once.
But the idea quickly runs into reality.
Gauthier is Anaheim’s issue right now, and the Ducks are tangled in a contract standoff with camp approaching. Mitchell notes that if Anaheim wants to get him signed, trade candidates like Frank Vatrano, Chris Kreider, and Alex Killorn could be on the way out.
Gauthier wants his money, especially after Leo Carlsson signed a five-year offer sheet deal at $18 million per season. Gauthier is not worth $18 million, but he is a 21-year-old who just scored 41 goals and is expected to be part of Anaheim’s core for a long time.
The whole pitch hinges on the possibility that Anaheim and Gauthier simply don’t work it out. If that happens, a trade could be on the table this summer.
From Edmonton’s side, Mitchell argues the Oilers have leaned too often on short-term veteran winger rentals in recent offseasons, banking on chemistry and a hot streak to keep another Cup push alive. His case is that the better move might be a heavy investment in something much more durable.
Gauthier, in that view, gives the Oilers something they have not had a real shot at in years: a young, cost-controlled scorer with real finish who could stay alongside Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl for years, not just for one playoff run. If there is a chance to trade for him, Mitchell believes Edmonton ought to be involved.
Of course, that’s where the dream gets expensive.
Edmonton does not have a stocked cupboard, and the cost to land Gauthier would be massive. Stan Bowman does not have much draft capital or organizational depth to work with, and Anaheim holds the leverage anyway. The Ducks do not have to move Gauthier, and they certainly do not have to move him to a division rival.
If the Oilers were to open talks, Mitchell’s sense is that Matthew Savoie, Ike Howard, and a high draft pick would be the outer limit of an offer. Even that might not be enough, especially with other teams able to assemble stronger prospect and pick packages without much strain.
Then there is the contract issue, which may be the biggest hurdle of all. Whatever Gauthier eventually signs for in Anaheim is expected to be significant, and Edmonton would almost certainly need to clear out an established roster player just to make the money fit.
That would mean plenty of turnover for one player, even one with Gauthier’s scoring touch. Mitchell also points to the reputation Gauthier has for working himself out of NHL organizations, which only adds another layer of caution for a team built to win now.
So yes, this is a long shot - maybe more than that. But if Gauthier truly becomes available, Mitchell’s view is that the Oilers should at least pick up the phone.
In Other News...
Dostl Sees One Huge Test Behind Anaheims Carlsson Decision
Luk Dostls new five-year extension gave the Ducks another major piece to sort out, and he was quick to make clear he supports the way Anaheim handled Leo Carlssons next contract. Carlsson has become one of the franchises cornerstone young players, and the Ducks were always going to face a pivotal decision on how hard to push to keep him in place as the roster continues to take shape around its top talent.
The bigger issue now is what comes next for Anaheims front office. Locking in Carlsson and Dostl gives the Ducks security at key positions, but it also leaves less room to maneuver as they try to build out the rest of the roster. The club has already had to weigh how these commitments affect its cap flexibility, and the pressure only grows from here as more decisions stack up. [Read more 🡒]
Ducks Prospect Faces A Big Question After Uneven First Pro Season
Konnor Smiths first full season in pro hockey gave the Ducks a clearer look at where he stands, and it was a mixed one. The 2023 draft pick spent time with both the AHLs San Diego Gulls and the ECHLs Tulsa Oilers, showing enough offense in Tulsa to hint at upside while also reminding Anaheim how much polish he still needs before he can push for a real NHL role.
For the Ducks, the bigger question now is less about whether Smith has tools worth watching and more about how he turns that raw talent into something more dependable. His production was uneven, his development path was split between two leagues, and that leaves Anaheim with a prospect who is still interesting, still in the mix, and still trying to prove he can translate flashes of promise into a more complete pro game. [Read more 🡒]
Ducks Prospect Has Real Upside But One Big NHL Question Remains
McQueen arrives in the Ducks system with the kind of upside that can make a draft pick feel exciting long before he reaches Anaheim. He played through a back injury during the 2023-24 season, then worked his way back late in the next season before the Ducks selected him, a reminder that his path has already included more grit than most prospects face this early.
The talent is there, but the next steps are just as clear. Coaches and analysts keep pointing to the same development points for McQueen as he moves forward: tightening up his defensive game and building more physical strength. For a player still sorting through what he can become at the NHL level, those areas may end up deciding how quickly his promise turns into something more concrete. [Read more 🡒]