Alabama’s path back into the College Football Playoff picture runs straight through Baton Rouge, and Paul Finebaum isn’t sugarcoating what’s at stake.
On ESPN’s “First Take” Monday, the analyst said the Crimson Tide’s Nov. 7 trip to LSU could make or break their postseason hopes after No. 13 Alabama fell 26-10 at Tennessee on Saturday. That loss gave Alabama back-to-back regular-season defeats for the first time since 2007, and Finebaum made it clear he views a third one as fatal.
“Right now, they’re looking at the abyss,” Finebaum said.
He pointed directly to LSU as the game that could slam the door.
“They have to go to LSU,” Finebaum said. “Now, LSU has been all over the place this year, but Alabama does not seem to play that well on the road.
I know they beat Mississippi State, but Kamario Taylor was out of that game. ... If they drop that game, they’re done.
They’re not getting in the playoff.”
Taylor did start for Mississippi State in the Oct. 3 game in Starkville, but the sophomore quarterback was dealing with an ankle injury and exited early in the fourth quarter of Alabama’s 56-23 win. The Tide’s other road victory came at Kentucky, where they trailed 17-13 at halftime before blowing the game open with a 32-0 second half in a 45-17 win.
LSU, meanwhile, is 5-2 under Lane Kiffin and moved up to No. 18 in the AP Top 25 after a 31-0 shutout of Mississippi State. Finebaum said he had already circled this matchup back in August, when he predicted Kiffin would get revenge on November 7 and deal Alabama its third loss.
The pressure on Alabama’s offense is only growing, and Finebaum said much of it has shifted to coordinator Ryan Grubb. Head coach Kalen DeBoer defended Grubb this week, saying, “I think he’s a great play-caller,” but Finebaum said the fan base has already turned.
“And the fans right now are not so much after DeBoer, they’re after Ryan Grubb, the offensive coordinator who called a miserable game Saturday,” Finebaum said. “They just got punked against Tennessee, a team that had struggled at times this year.”
That was a sharp fall from the way Alabama had been rolling early. Through five weeks, the offense was averaging 49.6 points per game.
In Knoxville, though, the Tide produced just 10 points, 201 total yards and four turnovers. Tennessee running back DeSean Bishop also gashed Alabama for 159 yards.
Grubb didn’t push back on the criticism.
“It’s embarrassing,” Grubb said. “If I was a fan or a supporter, I’d be pissed off too.”
Finebaum also connected the Tennessee loss to Alabama’s 20-17 home defeat to Georgia on Oct. 10, saying DeBoer had burned through the momentum from the previous week.
“DeBoer threw away all the goodwill he got a week ago in that loss to Georgia, but Alabama is really in trouble at the moment,” he said.
Alabama is 5-2 overall and 3-2 in the SEC. The Tide host Texas A&M on Saturday, then have an open date before that trip to Baton Rouge.
In Other News...
Alabama Could Catch Texas A&M At The Perfect Time
Texas A&Ms first injury report for Week 8 gives Alabama a clearer picture of the challenge ahead, and it comes with some notable absences. Wide receivers Terry Bussey and Kelshaun Johnson, along with offensive lineman Blake Ivy, were listed out, while several other key names landed in the questionable column as the buildup to Saturday continues. For an Alabama team trying to measure itself in conference play, any edge in availability matters, especially against a roster that has already had to manage its health carefully.
Mike Elko said the decision to rest injured players in the previous game was valuable for recovery, which is the kind of detail Alabama will be watching closely as the week unfolds. The report does not settle everything yet, but it does hint at a game that could look different depending on who is able to go, and that uncertainty is exactly what makes this matchup worth tracking all the way to kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama's Offensive Line Is Under Pressure After A Brutal Wake-Up Call
The day after Alabamas loss to Tennessee, the focus quickly turned to the line play that helped sink the offense. Starting right guard Michael Carroll owned up to the units struggles, and offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb also took responsibility as the Crimson Tide tried to sort through what went wrong. Offensive line coach Adrian Klemm went even further, calling the performance embarrassing and stressing that the standard has to be higher.
Now the challenge is less about words than response, with Texas A&M up next as a chance to show the problems were a one-game collapse rather than a deeper issue. Alabamas front has been put on notice, and the next outing will say a lot about whether the group can clean up the mistakes that were exposed in Knoxville. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama Faces A Troubling Injury Question Ahead Of Texas A&M
The SECs new injury reporting policy has already made Alabamas weekly picture a little clearer for conference games, and it also puts extra attention on the Tides health heading into Texas A&M. Zabien Brown and EJ Crowell are both dealing with lower leg injuries and are being evaluated, while Crowell is expected to practice during the week. Ryan Coleman-Williams had arthroscopic surgery for a meniscus injury and is not expected to practice, which adds another name to a growing list of players the staff has to monitor closely.
Racin Delgatty and Terrance Green are making progress, but both remain week-to-week, leaving Alabama with several situations still very much in motion. Jeremiah Beaman and Cayden Jones will miss the 2026 season because of ACL injuries, a reminder of how much depth can be tested over time even before the grind of October really settles in. For a team preparing for a major SEC matchup, the question is not just who is available now, but how many of these injury timelines can move in the right direction before Saturday. [Read more 🡒]