In a twist that few could have predicted a year ago, the basketball world is buzzing with a question: Should professional players be allowed to return to college hoops? This debate is heating up both on the court and in the courtroom, as several athletes who have tasted the professional game seek a return to college basketball.
Take Charles Bediako, for example. After two seasons with Alabama, he declared for the NBA Draft and spent three years in the G League.
He made a brief return to the Crimson Tide for five games before a court ruling halted his college comeback. Similarly, former UCLA standout Amari Bailey, who played 10 games in the NBA, is eyeing a return to college ball.
Meanwhile, James Nnaji joined Baylor after starting his pro career in Europe and being drafted in 2023, despite never playing in the NBA or college before.
Louisville’s London Johnson also made his way from the G League to college, marking his first collegiate experience last fall. During All-Star Weekend, The Athletic surveyed players on this hot topic, and the response was mostly negative.
Brooklyn Nets’ Egor Demin, who played at BYU after a stint in Spain, voiced a common sentiment: “I think there should be boundaries. Playing in the NBA and then returning to college seems unfair to the other guys.” Demin’s perspective is particularly relevant as he navigated a similar path, transitioning from playing professionally in Europe to college in the U.S.
Traditionally, American players who have played in the NBA or G League haven't had the same opportunities to return to college. Memphis Grizzlies’ Jaylen Wells, who played at Sonoma State and Washington State, added, “There’s a reason why they call you a pro. College is a different stage.”
Atlanta Hawks’ All-Star Jalen Johnson echoed this, saying, “Declaring for the draft is like saying you’re ready to be a pro. It takes away opportunities from other kids who want to get discovered.”
Orlando Magic rookie Jase Richardson, who spent a year at Michigan State, was firm: “Once you declare, you shouldn’t be able to go back.”
Only two players expressed any support for the idea. Washington Wizards’ Kyshawn George simply asked, “Why not?” while Toronto rookie Alijah Martin said, “To each his own.”
Alabama and coach Nate Oats have faced criticism for Bediako’s return, sparking a wave of eligibility efforts from other athletes who have left college for the pros. The controversy ties back to a 2024 federal court challenge led by former Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia, which resulted in the NCAA issuing an eligibility waiver for the 2025-26 season to athletes from junior colleges or non-NCAA schools. The NCAA has been entangled in 55 eligibility lawsuits, with mixed outcomes and ongoing cases.
As the debate rages on, the implications for college and professional basketball continue to evolve, leaving fans and players alike pondering the future of the sport.