Nate Oats Enters Preseason With Alabamas Biggest Questions Still Unsettled

As the Alabama basketball team gears up for the upcoming season, Nate Oats faces pivotal decisions with a newly reconstructed roster and the uncertainty surrounding key players.

Alabama basketball is almost at the point where the talking stops and the real answers start arriving.

In less than a week, the Crimson Tide will open exhibition play at Coleman Coliseum with Furman on Thursday, then take on SEC opponents Ole Miss and Auburn in two more preseason tune-ups before the regular season begins November 3 against Sam Houston. Nate Oats has spent the offseason rebuilding the roster through the Transfer Portal and an elite high school class, while also bringing back key pieces from last year. The result looks deep, talented and dangerous on paper.

But paper only gets you so far. If Alabama is going to be a true contender, a few major questions still hang over this team.

The biggest one starts with Aden Holloway. All signs have pointed toward his return this fall, but there still has not been an official announcement from the team or university.

Earlier this week, Holloway’s felony marijuana charges were officially dropped, which pointed toward him completing the second-chance program. That said, finishing the legal side does not automatically mean every team and university requirement has been satisfied.

It is still unclear what remains, and whether he will be available when preseason action begins against Furman.

If Holloway is back, Alabama’s backcourt instantly gets scarier. He averaged just under 17 points per game last season and shot 43.8% on 169 three-point attempts, making him one of the nation’s top shooters from deep. His presence changes everything for this roster.

That includes the next big swing factor: Amari Allen. He passed on the NBA Draft, where he was projected as a late first-round pick, and returned to Tuscaloosa for his sophomore season.

Labaron Philon did something similar the year before, came back, had a huge season and ended up being drafted 22nd overall by the Philadelphia 76ers. Allen is hoping for that same kind of rise, and if he makes it, he’ll be right in the mix for SEC Player of the Year.

Allen was already excellent as a do-it-all freshman in 2025-26. This season, he should have the ball in his hands even more.

The frontcourt brings its own set of questions, starting with Brandon Garrison. Alabama is counting on the Kentucky transfer to tap into the potential that has been obvious for a while.

He was solid over two seasons in Lexington, but the consistency never quite matched the talent, and his motor could come and go. Oats needs him to show up every night.

The upside is real. Garrison has the athleticism to help Alabama reshape its defense, and there is more to his offensive game than he has shown so far. That’s a big reason he landed in Tuscaloosa in the first place - Oats’ system fit what he wants to become.

And unlike last season, Alabama has options behind him. Aiden Sherrell was the lone playable big on the roster a year ago, but that is no longer the case. If Garrison struggles, Oats can turn to Mississippi State transfer Jamarion Davis-Fleming, sophomore Collins Onyejiaka, or move Boise State transfer Drew Fielder to the five.

That depth matters because Alabama’s defense has to move up a level. The Crimson Tide finished 61st in KenPom’s defensive efficiency metric last season, good enough to be strong but not elite. Oats will still run an offense built to score in bunches, but the season’s ceiling will come down to whether the defense catches up.

The roster construction suggests it can. With Garrison and Davis-Fleming in the frontcourt, Alabama may move away from drop coverage and switch more pick-and-rolls.

The added length on the perimeter should help too, with Cole Cloer, Jaxon Richardson and Tarris Bouie joining returner London Jemison. Allen should also spend more time on the wing, which means Holloway will usually be the only player shorter than 6-foot-5 on the floor.

Freshman Anderson Diaz should get minutes as well, though likely when Holloway is off the court.

Even with all that size and versatility, the final piece is whether Alabama’s young wings can catch up fast enough. Jemison is expected to start at the 3, with Holloway and Allen in the backcourt and Fielder and Garrison up front. The remaining wing minutes will likely be split among Cloer, Richardson and Bouie, and all three will be playing at this level for the first time.

The talent is there. Cloer is known as an elite shooter and should be ready to provide three-and-D value right away.

Richardson and Bouie bring outstanding athleticism and should be able to contribute through energy and effort even as they adjust. Jemison already showed promise as a freshman and should keep improving.

That’s the shape of Alabama’s roster as the season approaches: loaded with talent, packed with length, and full of questions that will decide how high this team can climb.

In Other News...

Derek Meadows Is Becoming An Alabama Concern For A Bigger Reason

Derek Meadows season has taken on an odd shape for Alabama, because the sophomore receiver arrived with some interest but has barely found a foothold once the games started. He had three catches for 44 yards in the opener, then went quiet, while Rico Scott has settled into the tertiary receiver spot behind Ryan Coleman-Williams and Lotzeir Brooks. For a passing game that always has room for another trusted target, the absence of any real uptick in Meadows usage has become noticeable.

Alabamas coaching staff has not increased his role, and that leaves Meadows in a tricky place as the season moves along. The competition around him is real, his path to steady snaps is unclear, and the longer he goes without earning more work, the more his future with the program starts to feel like part of the conversation. With other players pushing for touches and speculation already drifting toward a possible transfer, this is becoming more than a depth-chart issue for the Tide. [Read more 🡒]

Alabama Faces One Early Kickoff Test Before Mississippi State

Alabamas trip to Starkville comes with one of the more awkward scheduling quirks on the calendar, an 11 a.m. CT kickoff against Mississippi State that will send the Crimson Tide onto the road and into game mode before most stadiums are fully awake. It is the kind of setup that can test a teams routine, especially when travel and an early start are stacked together on the same day.

Bray Hubbard said the Tide are built for that kind of adjustment because their days already begin early with meetings and practice. For a program that leans on structure and pace throughout the week, the short turnaround between arrival and kickoff may be more of a nuisance than a hurdle, but it still adds a layer to a game Alabama will be expected to handle cleanly. [Read more 🡒]

Nick Saban Is Now At The Center Of An Uncomfortable Debate

Nick Sabans post-coaching profile has kept him in the middle of college footballs biggest conversations, and his latest involvement has only sharpened the spotlight. Since retiring after the 2023 season and moving into a broadcaster role with ESPN, the former Alabama coach has remained a powerful voice around the sport, including in his prominent push for the Protect College Sports Act.

Paul Finebaum, though, argued that Sabans presence in that debate may not resonate the way it once did, saying the Hall of Fame coach is out of step with todays players. Finebaum pointed to Georgias Kirby Smart as a sharper fit for the modern college football moment, creating an awkward contrast for a figure whose opinions still carry enormous weight in the sport and especially across the SEC. [Read more 🡒]