Paul Finebaum thinks Kalen DeBoer’s biggest challenge at Alabama isn’t just the schedule or the pressure that comes with the job. It’s Nick Saban.
Appearing on AL.com’s Alabama football podcast “Beat Everyone,” the ESPN and SEC Network host said DeBoer is dealing with a unique kind of scrutiny in Tuscaloosa because of who came before him. Alabama is 2-0, and the Tide have already shown they can survive ugly stretches and still finish strong - like the first half against Kentucky, when Crimson Tide fans were “boiling hot” before Alabama rolled to a 32-0 second-half surge.
That kind of comeback doesn’t erase the broader unease, though. Finebaum pointed to the way fans reacted after postseason losses to Georgia and Indiana, as well as regular-season defeats against Vanderbilt, Oklahoma and Florida State. Even with DeBoer taking Alabama to the SEC Championship Game and the College Football Playoff quarterfinal in his second season, the standard in Tuscaloosa remains brutal.
“Kalen DeBoer is different. That doesn’t mean he can’t work,” Finebaum said on the “Beat Everyone” podcast.
“And I was well aware that Nick Saban was also different, but Nick Saban had already won a national championship. And Nick Saban had the DNA of a serial killer, coaching-wise, I might add.
“Kalen DeBoer does not. Kalen DeBoer will put you to sleep if you listen to one of his press conferences for too long.
Nick Saban never did that. And that is what we’re talking about.
Does that mean he can’t win? No, but it’s what that means is when and if he gets in trouble, fans will turn on him because there’s a there’s a certain segment of the population, but they just are turned off by him.
And they’re turned off by him very, very quickly when things go badly. Where other coaches, people perhaps would hang in with a little bit longer.
So that’s what that’s why he’s vulnerable.”
Finebaum also said DeBoer has collected big wins, especially against Georgia in his first two seasons, but Alabama hasn’t always turned those moments into lasting momentum. In his view, the shadow Saban casts over the program makes that even harder.
“Kalen DeBoer has a Nick Saban problem and it’s not going away, and it’s not getting any better,” Finebaum said. “And every time Nick Saban says something as awkwardly stupid as he did a few weeks ago, like maybe Alabama will slip under the radar, people just get nauseated.
“Nick Saban has never picked against Alabama on ‘College GameDay. He will never say anything critical.
And it would be better if he did. He’s allowed to.
But instead, Nick Saban, no matter what he does, dominates the news cycle in Alabama.”
Finebaum said Saban’s presence remains unavoidable, whether he is out “shilling” for the Protect College Sports Act or helping keep Alabama in the conversation. He added that he doesn’t want Saban to disappear, noting that the former coach is clearly enjoying retirement.
“I’m not suggesting Nick Saban go away. He he’s having the time of his life,” Finebaum said.
“I had a long talk with him at the SEC Media Days this year, and we should all have a retirement like Nick Saban’s. Most of us will probably not, so I don’t want to take anything away from him.
He’s earned it.”
Still, Finebaum said the issue for DeBoer is simple: replacing the most celebrated coach in college football history comes with baggage, and it may take a more forceful personality to create some separation.
“What I’m talking about is some fiery guy who walks into that press conference and says, ‘I don’t care about Nick Saban,’” Finebaum said. “Like Pete Golding, for example.
Kalen DeBoer’s not like that. He tiptoes around Nick Saban.
“Do I think Kalen DeBoer likes Nick Saban over his shoulder? No.
Who would? But that’s what he has, and that’s what he’s stuck with.”
In Other News...
Alabama Faces One Big Receiver Question Before Florida State
Alabamas opening stretch has already brought a few roster changes into focus, and the receiver room is one of the more interesting ones as the Crimson Tide prepare for Florida State. Noah Rogers has yet to play this season while working back from a lower-body injury, but he appears to be nearing a return at a time when Alabama is still sorting out how its newer faces fit into the offense.
Florida State comes into the matchup carrying plenty of its own uncertainty after firing its athletic director, and the pressure around Mike Norvell only adds to the stakes of the game. For Alabama, the question is less about the headline outside the program and more about how quickly Rogers can get back on the field and give the Tide another option before a challenging early-season test. [Read more 🡒]
Alabamas Past Jeremy Pruitt Interest Is Suddenly Back In Focus
Jeremy Pruitts fight with the NCAA has returned to the spotlight in Alabama, where the state Supreme Court heard oral arguments in his lawsuit this week. The former Tennessee coach is challenging the NCAAs authority to handle the case in Alabama, putting a legal dispute tied to his firing and the punishment that followed back in front of a court with real implications for his coaching future.
Pruitt is seeking $100 million over the penalties he says stemmed from the NCAAs actions, including the six-year show-cause order that has limited his employment opportunities. The justices did not rule from the bench, so the case now moves into another waiting period while the court considers how to handle a dispute that Alabama fans have followed from the start because of where Pruitts career once intersected with their program. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama Gets A Needed O-Line Boost Before Florida State
Alabamas offensive line should get a timely lift heading into the Florida State game, with right guard Michael Carroll expected to be available after sitting out the previous matchup because of an injury. The freshman All-America pick has been back in practice, and his return would give the Tide a more settled look up front at a point in the season when every piece matters.
Carrolls presence also matters because Alabama is preparing for a Florida State team that can challenge defenses on the ground, putting even more pressure on the Tide to be firm at the point of attack. Getting him back gives Alabama a better chance to handle those physical demands and keep its offensive plans on schedule in a matchup where line play could shape the day. [Read more 🡒]