Kalen DeBoer is already finding out that at Alabama, the conversation never really stops at wins and losses. The Crimson Tide can point to the standard Bear Bryant and Nick Saban built - nearly 1,000 victories, 15 national championships and 30 conference titles - but the bar in Tuscaloosa is so high that even the process behind the roster is now under a microscope.
That’s the spot DeBoer is in heading into Year 3. He took over after Saban’s stunning retirement following the 2023 season, with Saban now working as an analyst on ESPN’s flagship college football show, "College GameDay."
DeBoer arrived after leading Washington to the national championship game, but his first two seasons at Alabama have not matched that kind of momentum. He is 20-8 and has reached the College Football Playoff once, only to watch Alabama get rolled 38-3 by Indiana in the quarterfinals.
That loss hit a nerve with Alabama fans because the Crimson Tide never looked like they belonged on the same field as the Hoosiers. Now the pressure is shifting beyond just the scoreboard. DeBoer has to prove that Alabama’s long-term roster plan can still work in the modern game.
Right now, the early signs are shaky. Alabama’s 2027 recruiting class is among the weakest in the SEC, with only 13 commits and a ranking of second-to-last in the league, ahead of only Mississippi State. The Crimson Tide also checked in at No. 9 in the SEC in the transfer portal team rankings for the 2026 cycle, a sign that they have not leaned heavily on portal help while continuing to treat high school recruiting as the core of the roster.
Paul Finebaum said that approach could end up defining DeBoer’s tenure.
"The philosophy at Alabama right now is to recruit and put the energy and effort on that," Finebaum said. "Alabama has not been overly active in the portal and has made some pretty big mistakes in there, as we have seen. It's a matter of whether this philosophy works, and I think whether it works or not will very well determine Kalen DeBoer's future."
There’s a logic to building through high school recruiting. It’s the more sustainable path, and it’s the way most programs should want to operate.
But that only holds up if the talent level stays elite. DeBoer has done that in his first two seasons, but this class has not yet matched Alabama’s usual standard.
Finebaum pointed out that this was always going to be a smaller group for the Crimson Tide, but even that explanation has limits. A reduced class doesn’t have to mean a near-bottom SEC finish. South Carolina and LSU each have just one more commit and are still ranked ahead of Alabama, while Vanderbilt and Tennessee have only two more.
July rankings won’t decide championships, and DeBoer still has time to change the picture before signing day. But at Alabama, the optics matter almost as much as the final record. If the Crimson Tide keep lagging behind SEC rivals on the recruiting trail while staying relatively quiet in the portal, the questions around DeBoer’s roster-building philosophy are only going to get louder.
In Other News...
Alabamas Summer League Class Faces Real Pressure Starting With Labaron Philon
Eight former Alabama basketball players are in line to spend part of July trying to turn Summer League minutes into something more meaningful, with the Tides recent pipeline to the NBA again giving the program a visible presence across the leagues showcase events. Labaron Philon, Latrell Wrightsell and Houston Mallette are among the names worth tracking, alongside Mark Sears, Chris Youngblood and Grant Nelson, as each one heads into a different setting with a different kind of opportunity in front of him.
Philons situation may be the most interesting of the group because his path to a role in Philadelphia is not as clean as it once looked. The Sixers have reshaped their backcourt and added more competition for minutes, which means Summer League is less about simply showing up and more about making a case that sticks, even before the games in Las Vegas really get rolling. [Read more 🡒]
Even Alabama Still Has Some Shockingly Close Firsts Left
For a program that has piled up 985 wins and 18 national championships over 134 years, Alabama still has an oddly long list of firsts left on the schedule. As the 2026-27 season arrives, the Crimson Tide have never lined up against 46 FBS programs, a mix that includes 10 from Power Four leagues and a broader group of opponents that, for one reason or another, have simply never crossed paths with the Tide.
Some of those gaps are surprising enough to make a future matchup feel like a small event in itself, especially with first-time games already on the calendar in the coming years. Alabama has a few of those dates circled already, and postseason pairings could always add another new name to the ledger, which is part of what makes a schedule around a blueblood so strangely unfinished. [Read more 🡒]