Alabama fans have experienced the highs and lows of college football recruiting, witnessing both top-tier talents and those who didn't quite meet expectations. Yet, nothing stings quite like the ones who got away. A few years have passed since the 2023 recruiting class, but some Crimson Tide supporters still feel the absence of Peter Woods, the highly-touted defensive tackle who chose Clemson over Alabama.
The Crimson Tide also saw a significant shift with James Smith and Qua Russaw, both standout players from Montgomery's Carver High School. Initially part of Nick Saban's squad, they spent just one year under his guidance before transitioning to play for Kalen DeBoer. Despite their leadership roles and significant playing time, they ultimately decided their paths to success lay elsewhere, opting for Ohio State.
James Smith, a defensive tackle, recently shed light on his decision to transfer. “When I came to visit, it felt like [Nick Saban’s Alabama],” Smith shared, highlighting the familiar intensity and intentionality he found at Ohio State. This move has left some Alabama fans questioning whether the current program maintains the same level of intensity that once defined it.
Smith had a productive junior season with the Crimson Tide, recording 28 tackles, 6.5 tackles for loss, 2.5 sacks, two quarterback hurries, and a pass breakup. However, he credits Ohio State's Ryan Day and his process for offering a more intense and purposeful environment.
As we look to the upcoming season, all eyes will be on Smith to see how he performs with the Buckeyes. The potential for a College Football Playoff matchup between Alabama and Ohio State adds an intriguing layer to this narrative.