The first AP preseason Top 25 of 2026 put Ohio State at No. 1, and most of the rest of the poll lined up with the way college football watchers expected it to. But a few teams landed higher than their rosters and résumés seem to justify.
Five programs stand out as the biggest reaches in the opening rankings: Georgia, LSU, Alabama, BYU and Washington.
Georgia sits at the top of that list for a reason. The Bulldogs won the SEC title last season, then got knocked out by Ole Miss in the Sugar Bowl quarterfinal, making it back-to-back one-and-done trips through the College Football Playoff.
Gunner Stockton is back for his second full season as the starter after throwing for 2,894 yards with 24 touchdowns and five interceptions, but Georgia had to replace most of its top pass catchers. The schedule also got tougher with the SEC moving to nine conference games this season.
Kirby Smart said in December that coaches around the league were concerned about the change, and Georgia’s hardest tests now include Oklahoma, plus road trips to Alabama and Ole Miss. It’s hard not to look at the Bulldogs and wonder whether their peak came in 2021 and 2022, when they won those national titles.
LSU is another team that looks overvalued in the poll. The Tigers went 7-6 last year, and Lane Kiffin is now in his first season in Baton Rouge after the school fired Brian Kelly.
Sam Leavitt is taking over an offense rebuilt through the transfer portal, but the Arizona State transfer missed the back half of 2025 with a foot injury and threw for just 1,628 yards in seven games. He also had a shortened spring, which meant fall camp became a crash course in timing with new receivers.
The early schedule gives LSU no breathing room, and ranking the Tigers at No. 11 feels like a best-case scenario that may already be too optimistic.
Alabama also looks a bit rich at No. 15, even if that’s only a small jump from where it sat in my own projection. The bigger issue is the uncertainty at quarterback.
Austin Mack and Keelon Russell have been competing since spring, and neither has more than 70 snaps of experience. Offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb said the first fall scrimmage on Aug. 13 probably won’t decide the job, which means Kalen DeBoer still has to settle the position before East Carolina comes to Tuscaloosa on Sept.
- The Crimson Tide are trying to move on from a rough finish, too, after losing to Georgia in the SEC Championship and then falling 38-3 to Indiana in the Rose Bowl.
The Big 12 brings its own question mark in BYU. The Cougars finished 12-2 last season and made the Big 12 championship game, but both losses came against Texas Tech, including the title game, and that kept them out of the Playoff.
Bear Bachmeier threw for 3,033 yards as a true freshman and set a school record with 11 rushing touchdowns, yet the sophomore ranked 107th nationally in yards per attempt on throws beyond 20 yards. Running back LJ Martin had shoulder surgery and missed the Pop-Tarts Bowl.
Kalani Sitake still hasn’t won a Big 12 title or finished in the top 10 in Provo, and this year’s path runs through Texas Tech again. Even with the Red Raiders carrying more negative headlines than positive this offseason, they won’t be an easy out.
Washington rounds out the group, even after climbing four spots from my projection to No. 21 in the AP poll. Jedd Fisch went 9-4 in his second season in Seattle, and Demond Williams Jr. returned after briefly considering other options in January.
The junior passed for 3,065 yards with 25 touchdowns and added 611 rushing yards. Still, an eight-win season might be the realistic bar here despite the bigger expectations around the Huskies entering 2026.
If Ohio State, Oregon and Indiana belong in the Big Ten’s top tier, Washington looks more like a team sitting in the next group - closer to Nebraska than to USC, Penn State or Michigan.
In Other News...
Alabama Already Faces An EJ Crowell Question It Didn't Want
A lower-body injury has put freshman Alabama running back EJ Crowell on the shelf just as the preseason competition is starting to sharpen, and the timing is less than ideal for a player the Tide have been eager to see in a fuller role. Crowell missed Thursdays scrimmage and Mondays practice, another brief setback in a stop-and-start arrival that has already included injury issues since he got to campus.
Offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb has tried to keep the focus on the long view, expressing optimism that Crowell will be back soon and should be ready for the season opener. For Alabama, the hope is simple enough: get the freshman healthy, get him on the field, and find out whether the flashes he has shown when available can translate into something more meaningful once the games begin to count. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama's QB Battle May Be Reaching A Brutal Week For Austin Mack
The quarterback competition at Alabama has reached the point where the calendar may matter almost as much as the reps. Kalen DeBoer has made clear he would like to settle the job soon after the final fall camp scrimmage, with the staff trying to give the offense some much-needed continuity before the season begins. For now, the battle is centered on Austin Mack, a fourth-year player, and Keelon Russell, the sophomore who has worked himself into the thick of it.
Mack has stayed in the mix long enough to keep this from feeling settled, but the next few days could still be decisive in a fight that has already put real pressure on the veteran. Even if the answer does not come immediately, Alabama is clearly heading toward a choice it hopes will steady the entire offense, and the tension around that decision is only going to sharpen as the scrimmage approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Alabamas Quarterback Race Is Starting To Reveal Something Important
Alabamas 10th preseason camp practice offered another glimpse into how the quarterback competition is unfolding, even without the full-on offense-versus-defense setting fans usually crave. With media watching only a portion of the workout in Tuscaloosa, the session leaned heavily on group and individual work, which still gave a useful look at the rotation between Austin Mack and Keelon Russell while the staff kept sorting through battles along the offensive line.
The other notable development was the return of Lotzeir Brooks, who was back on the field and appeared to be fully involved after missing the previous scrimmage. Kalen DeBoer also spent a significant stretch working with the defense, a reminder that camp remains a broad evaluation process rather than a single-position showcase, and this one wrapped up after the seventh period with more questions than answers still hanging in the air. [Read more 🡒]