The College Football Playoff picture for Alabama is about to get a fresh update Tuesday night, and the biggest question hanging over the Tide is simple: how much does the Iron Bowl really matter now?
The selection committee’s latest rankings will help sort out where Alabama stands against Texas and Tennessee, and that could shape the rest of Thanksgiving week. ESPN’s Heather Dinich projected Sunday that Texas could move ahead of Alabama, and the Longhorns do have an edge in two of ESPN’s key numbers. Texas is now No. 4 in strength of record and No. 6 in strength of schedule, while Alabama slipped to No. 7 in strength of record and No. 18 in strength of schedule after its win over Chattanooga.
Still, committee chairman Hunter Yurachek pointed to Alabama’s body of work in the SEC, noting the Tide has a 22-point margin of victory in its six conference wins. Texas, after its 45-3 win Saturday over Arkansas, has beaten SEC opponents by an average of 16 points.
The resume comparison gets even messier when you look at ranked wins. Texas has victories over current CFP top-25 teams in Tennessee, Ohio State and Ole Miss.
Alabama’s wins over current CFP top-25 teams are Kentucky and South Carolina. Tuesday night will also bring another wrinkle: where Ohio State, Kentucky and South Carolina land, if they’re ranked at all, and whether Missouri returns to the top 25 after improving to 7-4 with its win over Kentucky.
Texas has a win over Missouri.
The bigger Alabama questions go beyond one ranking release.
First, can the Tide still reach the SEC championship game? That path looks shaky.
Alabama would need Mississippi State to upset Ole Miss in the Egg Bowl to have a shot at a three-way tiebreaker with Texas and Tennessee. If that doesn’t happen, Alabama would need both Texas and Tennessee to lose to Texas A&M and Vanderbilt, respectively.
If Texas ends up in the CFP ahead of Alabama, there’s another possible twist: what happens if the Longhorns lose in Atlanta? The committee, with a different makeup last season, did not knock Alabama down for losing to Georgia in the SEC championship game.
Second, is Alabama already a playoff lock? Not quite, at least according to the numbers.
ESPN’s metrics dropped Alabama’s playoff probability from 96.8% to 91.5% after Saturday’s results. If Alabama were to lose to Auburn and also miss the SEC title game, its path would get much harder.
ESPN hasn’t released that exact scenario, but Alabama would likely need to stay in the top seven among at-large teams with three losses, something that has never happened.
Other models are far more bullish. The Athletic’s computer model gives Alabama a 99% chance to make the playoff.
DraftKings no longer lists playoff odds for the Tide. FanDuel still has Alabama at -20000 to make the playoff and +3000 to miss it.
Third, even if Alabama gets in, can it still land a first-round bye? That remains unresolved.
If the Tide beats Auburn, misses the SEC championship game and stays in the committee’s top four by December 6, it could still grab one of those bye spots. Tuesday’s rankings will offer the first real clue about whether that’s in play.
There are other moving parts too. Notre Dame’s placement by December 6 matters, along with how high the committee ranks the ACC championship game winner, whether that’s Miami or Wake Forest, and the Big Ten champion, with Oregon, Iowa, UCLA and Indiana all still possible.
For now, The Athletic’s model gives Alabama a 55% chance at a first-round bye, ahead of Texas at 38% and Tennessee at 36%.
And if Alabama doesn’t get that bye? It would still be in strong position to host a home playoff game on December 18 or 19.
In Other News...
Alabama Heads Into Iron Bowl With One Big Availability Question
After Alabama handled Chattanooga, Kalen DeBoer spent part of his postgame update sorting through the injury picture that always seems to matter more in late November. Backup quarterback Austin Mack got the start, while starter Keelon Russell sat out with an ankle injury, though DeBoer said Russell is expected back to full practice next week. It was the kind of checkpoint Alabama wanted to get through cleanly, with the Iron Bowl looming and the staff trying to get as many pieces as possible pointed in the right direction.
The good news for Alabama is that Russell was not the only player DeBoer sounded upbeat about. Chuck McDonald III, Luke Metz, Mal Waldrep Jr. and Ivan Taylor also dealt with injury-related absences or issues, but the coach expressed optimism about their availability for Auburn. With rivalry week arriving, the Tide still have one major question to answer, and the next few days of practice should tell the story. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama Just Put Its Quarterback Picture Back In Focus
Alabamas quarterback situation got a little more interesting Saturday, even in a game that never really felt in doubt. With starter Keelon Russell resting against Chattanooga, Austin Mack got the nod and made the most of the opportunity, guiding an offense that rolled from the opening minutes while the defense smothered the visitors and held them under 100 yards of total offense.
Macks efficient afternoon, paired with a strong ground game, gave the Crimson Tide a clean look at the depth behind Russell and, just as importantly, a chance to see freshman Jett Thomalla in the second half. Thomalla flashed enough to keep the backup conversation alive, and with Alabama entering the stretch run, the pecking order behind its starter suddenly looks like something worth watching. [Read more 🡒]
Tim Tebow Just Added Fuel To Tennessees Alabama Ranking Debate
The latest College Football Playoff rankings debate has found another voice, and this one came from Tim Tebow, who weighed in on the Alabama-Tennessee comparison with a familiar mix of football logic and old SEC tension. Tebow said Alabama looks better on the field than Tennessee overall, but he also argued that the head-to-head result should carry real weight after the Crimson Tide were heavily beaten in their meeting.
He also pointed to Alabamas more dynamic quarterback play as a reason the gap between the two teams exists in the rankings. Still, the conversation is far from settled, especially with Tennessee heading into an LSU game that could reshape how both teams are viewed when the next round of rankings arrives. [Read more 🡒]
