With Alabama’s seven-game run against Power 4 opponents finally in the rearview, the bye week offers a chance to sort through what this offense has really been, not just what it looked like at its peak. Expectations shifted fast this season.
After the Mississippi State win, Alabama looked like a national championship contender. After back-to-back losses, that idea got knocked back down hard.
So the cleaner question is this: how has each part of the offense stacked up against what was expected before the season began?
At quarterback, Keelon Russell has been close to the statistical mark many expected, but the overall feel has been a little different. The playmaking is there, and the scrambling damage is no surprise.
What has stood out more is the inconsistency as a thrower. The issue isn’t just hero ball or the bad sacks that come with it; it’s the stretches of inaccuracy that have shown up again and again outside that 2.5-game stretch from the second half of FSU through MSU.
The arm talent and improvisation are clear. The polish, not quite as much.
The ask now is simple: make the routine throws more consistently and lean less on scramble-play fireworks.
The backfield has been a more mixed story, though not a discouraging one. Daniel Hill has clearly outperformed expectations, showing much more confidence as a runner than many would have projected.
Trae’Shawn Brown has basically done what was expected, even if he has played more than anticipated. EJ Crowell is the strange case - every time he’s had a real opportunity, he’s flashed beyond what was expected, but he’s had very few normal touches and has also been injured for a couple of weeks.
The preseason belief was that Crowell might emerge as the main back by midseason, but that hasn’t happened. As a unit, the group lands right about where it was supposed to.
Receiver has been the most uneven room on offense. Ryan Coleman-Williams had been on pace to surpass expectations before the knee injury and then UGA “teeing off on his head,” and he has mostly hit the level many anticipated.
Lotzeir Brooks, though, has fallen well short. Rico Scott came in without much hype and spent most of the season living down to that, including one of the worst catch rates in the SEC, before something seemed to click last week.
Beyond that, Cederian Morgan, Noah Rogers and Derek Meadows have all underperformed. Taken together, it’s one of the more disappointing groups on the team.
Tight end, on the other hand, has been a smash hit. This group has gone way beyond expectations, both in the run game and as pass targets.
The blocking is described as night and day from last season, and there are a lot of bodies contributing. Marshall Pritchett has been one of the most reliable receiving options on the roster, while Kaleb Edwards has shown a real feel for sitting down in zones, picking up easy first downs, and then turning forward to create after the catch.
It’s been the most fun group on the offense.
The offensive line has also cleared the bar, even if the last two weeks have blurred the picture a bit. Coming into the year, the expectation was more basic competence, not this level of improved play.
As the unit started to click, the standard kept rising. By the point a Tennessee edge rusher beat Jackson Lloyd cleanly, it felt shocking because it had been such a rare sight all season.
Overall, the line has gone well beyond expectations, especially Lloyd and Jayvin James at tackle. While Russell has taken plenty of sacks, many of them came on blitzes or on plays where he held the ball too long trying to create something.
Very few were true one-on-one losses up front. The run game has also been much better than in recent years, helped by sharper blocking awareness.
The downturn over the last few weeks is real, but across the full season this has been a pleasant surprise.
Put it all together and the offense has slightly exceeded expectations. That is mostly because of what the tight ends and offensive line have provided, even with the clunkers against UGA and Tennessee.
There’s still reason to feel good if Ryan Coleman-Williams, Racin Delgatty and EJ Crowell keep moving toward full health, and if Keelon Russell keeps growing into a steadier version of himself. But there’s also the shadow of the last two seasons, when Alabama’s offense faded hard in the final third of the year.
That doubt is still hanging around.
In Other News...
Alabama Still Has One Noah Rogers Decision Hanging Over The Offense
Noah Rogers has been back in the mix since Week 4, but Alabama still has not fully unlocked what it wants from the NC State transfer. A knee injury in spring practice slowed his rollout, and while the staff has clearly been interested in finding more room for him on offense, the challenge has been fitting him into an already crowded rotation without pulling someone else off the field.
Kalen DeBoer has said the Tide would like to involve Rogers more, which leaves this as more than a simple health update. It is a usage question now, and one that will keep lingering as Alabama sorts out how to balance its personnel. Elsewhere around the program, sophomore guard Amari Allen is entering the year with some real buzz after being named preseason All-SEC first team by league coaches following a strong freshman season and a solid preseason showing. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama Heads To LSU With DeBoer Taking A Very Different Approach
The Alabama-LSU matchup on Nov. 7 already carried plenty of weight, but Lane Kiffin helped sharpen the edge by calling out the SECs decision to put the game in an afternoon window and suggesting the schedule favors LSU. His comments added another layer to a rivalry that rarely needs much help getting attention, especially with both programs entering a stretch where every move feels magnified.
Kalen DeBoer, meanwhile, has taken a noticeably different tack in the buildup, keeping the focus on Alabama rather than joining the public back-and-forth. With LSU dealing with injuries and the stakes obvious for the Crimson Tide, the game sets up as one of those November tests that can reshape the conversation around Alabama almost immediately, depending on how it plays out. [Read more 🡒]
Kalen DeBoer Just Landed In An Alabama Scenario Fans Will Hate
Kalen DeBoer is already getting pulled into the kind of rumor mill Alabama fans never want to see around a coach who is still settling in. After signing a long-term deal with the Crimson Tide, DeBoer has nevertheless surfaced as a name to watch if USC ever decides to make a change with Lincoln Riley, whose tenure in Los Angeles has yet to produce a national championship or a College Football Playoff berth.
For Alabama, the concern is obvious: whenever a coach starts showing up on another blue-bloods wish list, the speculation follows. DeBoers contract was built to give the Tide stability, but the USC angle keeps his name in circulation for a job that would be hard for any coach to ignore, and it leaves Alabama fans waiting to see whether the noise fades or grows louder. [Read more 🡒]