The first College Football Playoff rankings of the 2026 season wasted no time stirring up a fight, and Paul Finebaum jumped right into the middle of it.
On Wednesday’s edition of ESPN’s Get Up, the ESPN analyst went after the committee’s handling of Alabama and Tennessee, zeroing in on the gap between the two 6-2 teams. Alabama landed at No. 5, while Tennessee checked in at No. 13, even though the Volunteers beat the Crimson Tide earlier this season.
Finebaum made it clear he didn’t buy the logic behind Alabama’s spot, especially with Tennessee carrying the head-to-head win. He said the rankings were unusually difficult to understand and took direct aim at Alabama’s placement.
The reaction fits into a broader argument that always follows these rankings: how much should the committee value the full résumé compared with what happened on the field in a head-to-head matchup? Alabama’s schedule includes several tough opponents, which could be part of why the committee is leaning its way.
But Tennessee fans have a simple answer to that. Their team beat Alabama and still ended up eight spots lower.
The committee, though, does not treat head-to-head as an automatic trump card. It weighs strength of schedule, results against quality opponents and direct matchups, and committee chair Hunter Yurachek has said those comparisons matter most when teams are close together in the rankings. That framework may help explain the separation here, but it hasn’t done much to quiet the noise.
Both teams now get another chance to shape the conversation this weekend. Alabama goes on the road to face No.
14 LSU, while Tennessee takes on No. 6 Kentucky.
Those results will give the committee more to chew on before the next set of rankings comes out.
A big Alabama win would help steady its place. A Tennessee win over another ranked opponent would only strengthen the Volunteers’ case. For now, Finebaum’s criticism has given the debate another loud voice, and the rankings have already produced one of the season’s most controversial comparisons.
In Other News...
Alabama Heads To LSU With One Big Availability Question
With the Southeastern Conference now requiring injury reports for football, basketball and baseball conference games starting in 2024, Alabamas weekly availability picture has become part of the conversation as much as the matchup itself. Heading into its seventh SEC game of the 2026 season against LSU, the Crimson Tide is still sorting through a roster that has been hit by injuries, even as head coach Kalen DeBoer said several previously sidelined players are making progress in their recoveries.
There is still no shortage of uncertainty around the depth chart, though, and Alabama is carrying some season-ending absences into this stretch, including Jeremiah Beaman and Cayden Jones. For a team entering one of the SECs biggest rivalry games, the question is less about who is already ruled out and more about which of the recovering players can actually make it back in time to matter against LSU. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama Heads Into LSU Week With One Big Availability Problem
Alabamas first availability report for LSU week brought a familiar kind of late-season concern, with five starters and one key running back listed as questionable because of injuries. There is some optimism around several of those names, including Ryan Coleman-Williams, Terrance Green and Racin Delgatty, but the list also leaves room for real uncertainty as the Crimson Tide work through the week.
Zabien Brown, Will Sanders and EJ Crowell are among the players whose status remains less clear, and that is where the issue starts to matter beyond just the injury report itself. How much depth Alabama has to lean on, and how effective it can be if a few of those pieces are limited or unavailable, could shape the way this matchup with LSU unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Alabama Faces A Brutal LSU Warning Ahead Of Playoff Test
The buildup to Alabamas next test has turned into a warning label, and Joel Klatt is not sugarcoating it. In previewing the matchup with LSU, the Fox Sports analyst pointed to the Tigers pass rush and overall defensive play as the kind of pressure that can expose some of Alabamas recent issues on the ground, a concern that matters even more with the playoff picture tightening.
Klatt also leaned into LSUs recent momentum at quarterback, noting Sam Leavitts strong play, while the injury situation for both teams adds another layer to a game that already feels like a measuring stick. He went as far as to pick LSU to win, projecting a 30-17 final, which only sharpens the stakes for Alabama as it heads into a matchup where the margin for error looks thin. [Read more 🡒]