Alabama Is At The Center Of CFP Outrage Again

In a controversial move that's stirring debate, the CFP selection committee's favoritism towards Alabama raises questions over inconsistent ranking standards.

When the College Football Playoff committee rolled out its latest rankings, Alabama got the kind of treatment that makes the whole exercise look a little too convenient. Last week’s logic vanished.

Last week’s punishment for a bad résumé update didn’t show up this time. For the Crimson Tide, the rules apparently took the night off.

That’s the part that jumps out first: Alabama stayed No. 3 even after its résumé took hit after hit. Kentucky, the Tide’s sketchiest signature win, lost again, this time at home to Florida.

South Carolina got thumped on the road by 4-6 Arkansas. Mississippi State dropped its sixth straight.

Texas A&M lost at home to Tennessee. LSU lost at home to Texas.

All five SEC teams Alabama beat lost, and still the Tide didn’t move.

Chair Hunter Yurachek said Alabama’s strength of schedule and strength of record were not hurt by that collective collapse. He also pointed to the Tide’s win over Vanderbilt, the SEC’s co-last-place team, as part of the case.

“We’ve seen throughout this college football season after a big win like Alabama had at LSU, a team will let down and lose those games,” Yurachek said, glossing over the fact that LSU is 6-4 and now unranked. “Credit to Alabama not paying their best in Nashville and finding a way to win.”

That line would land differently if winning in Nashville were some kind of mountain climb. Arkansas, the SEC’s 13th-place team, did it a month ago. North Carolina State, tied for last in the ACC, would have done it in September if not for an all-time meltdown on the last play.

The committee’s affection for Alabama has become hard to miss. After the Tide beat Chattanooga on Saturday, they still control their own path.

Beat Auburn on Nov. 28 and they’re in the CFP, with a shot at a top-four seed and no worse than a home playoff opener. Even a lopsided loss to Georgia in the SEC championship game might not change much, because the committee already showed last year it was willing to shrug off a three-touchdown beatdown in Atlanta.

That’s what makes the rest of the rankings so frustrating. Texas sits at No. 5 with the same number of losses as Alabama and better wins.

Tennessee, which beat Alabama by 16 points in a game that turned into a second-half mismatch, fell a spot to No. 9 after a 15-point road win. Meanwhile, Indiana moved ahead of the Volunteers after beating No.

17 USC by two touchdowns.

Yurachek’s explanation for Indiana was different from the one used on Alabama. Instead of leaning on strength of schedule and strength of record, he said the Hoosiers’ improved offense helped them rise. The criteria, at least from the outside, still looks like it’s being applied one way in one case and another way in the next.

The committee’s own Top 25 is also doing a lot of work for the SEC. South Carolina is No. 21 despite a 28-point loss to a team with a losing record.

Oklahoma is No. 22 after a loss to unranked, 5-5 Michigan. Florida is No. 24, with every loss coming by at least 16 points.

Mississippi is No. 25, even though it has dropped three of its last four and now leans heavily on a Sept. 6 win over Louisville.

“If you beat a team that’s ranked in our Top 25, that’s significant for us,” Yurachek said.

That’s the loop the committee keeps feeding. It ranks SEC teams, then uses those rankings to justify more SEC teams.

Eight league teams are in the Top 25 right now, which creates more “quality wins” by definition. At the same time, 6-4 Big Ten teams Wisconsin, Illinois, Penn State, Northwestern, Washington and Nebraska are left out, which weakens the value of wins by Indiana, Iowa, Oregon and Ohio State.

The Big Ten has its own issues here. Five of its teams did not play a power-conference opponent outside league play: Indiana, Nebraska, Penn State, Washington and USC.

The SEC, meanwhile, finally moved to nine conference games, and that became a major talking point in the push for more playoff bids. Yurachek brought up the ninth game Tuesday night, even though none of the SEC teams has played it yet.

So yes, the four SEC teams that should make the tournament are in decent shape. But Alabama remains the glaring exception, the team the committee keeps propping up no matter what the rest of the board says.

In Other News...

Former Saban Assistant Suddenly Enters The Coaching Carousel Conversation

Arkansas States decision to move on from Butch Jones after six seasons has added another familiar name to the coaching carousel. Jones went 30-43 with the Red Wolves, but he also helped guide the program to three straight bowl appearances, a stretch that gave the school some stability even as the results never fully matched the standard it wanted.

For Alabama fans, Jones is another former Saban staffer whose next step now becomes part of the wider coaching conversation. Before landing at Arkansas State, he spent time in Tuscaloosa as an offensive analyst and special assistant under Nick Saban, and his availability could make him a name to watch as openings around the sport continue to sort themselves out. [Read more 🡒]

Keelon Russell Debate Just Got More Complicated For Alabama Fans

As Alabama worked through the early part of its season, the conversation around first-year starter Keelon Russell was never just about talent. Former Crimson Tide quarterback AJ McCarron added another layer to it this week, saying it mattered for Russell to be out there against Vanderbilt even while dealing with an ankle injury, because live reps are part of what helps a young quarterback settle in and keep the offense on schedule.

McCarron pointed to his own 2011 experience playing through injury as a reminder of how much timing and execution can depend on staying on the field. Russell answered with a strong performance in Alabamas win over Vanderbilt, throwing three touchdowns and giving the staff and fan base a clearer look at what he can provide even when he is not at full strength. [Read more 🡒]

Georgia Playoff Debate Just Gave Bulldogs Fans A New December Question

ESPNs latest round of College Football Playoff projections has only sharpened the conversation around Georgia, with most of the networks experts slotting the Bulldogs as a top seed. Even in a year when the SEC is expected to be well represented, the broader picture still includes Alabama, Texas and Tennessee as teams projected to land in the field, a reminder of how crowded the race has become at the top.

For Georgia fans, the interesting wrinkle is not simply whether the Bulldogs get in, but where they end up when the bracket is finally set. Two ESPN experts pushed Georgia lower than the rest of the panel, which is the kind of split that keeps December interesting and leaves room for debate until the official selections arrive. [Read more 🡒]