Alabama Is At The Center Of Another CFP Favoritism Fight

Amid accusations of favoritism, the College Football Playoff committee faces scrutiny for controversial ranking decisions, with Alabama's placement at the center of the debate.

College football’s latest playoff rankings gave Alabama another boost, and Josh Pate didn’t waste much time calling out what he sees as a double standard.

The analyst took aim at the College Football Playoff selection committee Tuesday night after the 8-2 Crimson Tide stayed at No. 3, while 9-1 Indiana remained down at No. 8.

In a video posted to X, Pate said, “You treated Alabama differently than you treated Indiana,” Pate said in a video posted to X. “And I know you could sit there and say, ‘Josh, maybe they just think Alabama is better than Indiana.’

I don’t care what they think.”

Alabama’s placement held steady after a 21-6 win at Vanderbilt, even though the five SEC teams it had beaten all lost the previous weekend. The Tide’s two defeats came against No.

1 Georgia and No. 9 Tennessee, and the committee’s own release pointed out that no two-loss team had ever been ranked this high in a season’s third rankings.

Committee chair Hunter Yurachek defended the decision by saying those losses carried “very minimal for Alabama because of the quality of the strength of schedule” of those opponents. He also highlighted Alabama’s 22.5-point average margin in six SEC wins.

Indiana, meanwhile, did not get the same kind of treatment when the rankings shifted a week earlier. The Hoosiers dropped from No. 4 to No. 9 during their bye after teams they had beaten lost, and Yurachek called them “the victim of having a bye week.”

Indiana then climbed one spot after beating No. 18 USC, 27-13, and its lone loss remains a 19-15 defeat to Ohio State.

Pate wasn’t buying the committee’s explanation that the process is being applied evenly. “I call BS on that,” he said.

“No, you’re not. No, you are not.”

He also mocked the idea that the committee’s football instincts should be taken at face value. “You ever wonder why retired coaches don’t all get super, super rich betting on football?”

Pate said. “With that football judgment of theirs, why don’t they just clean up?”

For Pate, the issue is simple: the committee needs a standard that makes the eye test less important. “It’s about merit, as much as we can define that,” he said.

“And you didn’t do that here. So I don’t buy any of what they said about that.”

Indiana coach Curt Cignetti made a similar point after the USC win. “You get tired of the narratives sometimes,” Cignetti said.

“‘Quality win’ because ‘Joe Smith’ was playing at the time. They ain’t won a game since, but it was a quality win back then.

I guess bad losses don’t count anymore.”

Former Alabama coach Nick Saban also criticized last week’s rankings on ESPN’s “College GameDay.”

Alabama’s next game is against Chattanooga, and the committee’s fourth rankings are set for Tuesday, Nov. 24, at about 7:30 p.m. ET on ESPN.

In Other News...

Former Saban Assistant Suddenly Enters The Coaching Carousel Conversation

Arkansas States decision to move on from Butch Jones after six seasons has added another familiar name to the coaching carousel. Jones went 30-43 with the Red Wolves, but he also helped guide the program to three straight bowl appearances, a stretch that gave the school some stability even as the results never fully matched the standard it wanted.

For Alabama fans, Jones is another former Saban staffer whose next step now becomes part of the wider coaching conversation. Before landing at Arkansas State, he spent time in Tuscaloosa as an offensive analyst and special assistant under Nick Saban, and his availability could make him a name to watch as openings around the sport continue to sort themselves out. [Read more 🡒]

Keelon Russell Debate Just Got More Complicated For Alabama Fans

As Alabama worked through the early part of its season, the conversation around first-year starter Keelon Russell was never just about talent. Former Crimson Tide quarterback AJ McCarron added another layer to it this week, saying it mattered for Russell to be out there against Vanderbilt even while dealing with an ankle injury, because live reps are part of what helps a young quarterback settle in and keep the offense on schedule.

McCarron pointed to his own 2011 experience playing through injury as a reminder of how much timing and execution can depend on staying on the field. Russell answered with a strong performance in Alabamas win over Vanderbilt, throwing three touchdowns and giving the staff and fan base a clearer look at what he can provide even when he is not at full strength. [Read more 🡒]

Alabama Is At The Center Of CFP Outrage Again

The latest College Football Playoff rankings have Alabama sitting at No. 3 again, and the reaction has been immediate. Even with some of the teams the Crimson Tide have beaten losing in the weeks since, the selection committee kept Alabama in place, a decision that has only added to the familiar debate around how much weight gets placed on strength of schedule, record and the eye test.

Committee chair Hunter Yurachek pointed to Alabamas rsum when explaining the placement, but the broader criticism is less about one team than the way the criteria seem to shift from week to week. Indianas drop despite not playing only sharpened the sense that the committee is applying its standards unevenly, and Alabama is once again right in the middle of the conversation whether it asked for it or not. [Read more 🡒]