Toronto Maple Leafs fans have a good reason to keep an eye on what happens in Anaheim with Cutter Gauthier, even if the Ducks winger has nothing directly to do with Toronto’s on-ice business.
The connection runs through Matthew Knies. Back in the summer of 2025, Knies signed a six-year extension with a $7.75 million AAV, and now Gauthier - a similar player, just a year or two further behind in his development - is on the verge of landing a contract that could come in at roughly double that number per season.
Gauthier is still unsigned as a restricted free agent, but the numbers being floated around him have climbed fast. The latest chatter points to a deal in the $15-17 million AAV range, and one report says he may not accept anything below the $18 million AAV Leo Carlsson just received from Anaheim after his offer-sheet battle with Philadelphia.
That makes Knies’ contract look better by the day.
The two players are not carbon copies, but the overlap is obvious. Both are big left wings who bring a power element and do most of their damage around the crease rather than as pure distributors.
Gauthier just finished a massive breakout season, piling up 41 goals and 28 assists for 69 points in 76 games. He also added 11 power-play goals and seven game-winners.
Knies posted big numbers of his own. This past season, he set new career highs with 23 goals and 43 assists for 66 points in 79 games, and he had already shown growth the year before with 29 goals and 58 points.
Where Gauthier is viewed more as a finisher, Knies is more of a classic power forward with skill. Reports have framed Gauthier as a legitimate 40-goal threat, and Sportsnet put him among the league’s top young talents.
NHL Edge has him in the 99th percentile for hardest shot. Knies, meanwhile, does a lot of his scoring from the dirty areas - tipping pucks, crashing the net, and finishing rebounds.
There’s another important similarity: both entered restricted free agency without arbitration rights, and both are key pieces for their teams going forward. Gauthier is 22.
Knies is 23. Neither is finished, and both organizations are betting on more growth over the next several seasons.
The bigger picture is where the contract comparison really starts to sting for Anaheim. The Ducks are feeling the pressure of a rising cap, and Gauthier’s negotiations are happening right in the wake of the Carlsson deal, which only came together after Philadelphia forced Anaheim’s hand with an offer sheet. That reset the market for young forwards, and it left the Ducks with very little leverage to push Gauthier down.
Toronto, on the other hand, got in ahead of that wave. Knies’ extension came together quietly over a summer weekend, alongside John Tavares’ extension, with none of the drama that has followed Gauthier’s situation.
At the time, $7.75 million looked like a team-friendly number. Now it could be one of the best bargains in the league.
Knies also took a discount to remain with the Maple Leafs, while Gauthier is expected to squeeze Anaheim for as much as he can get. If a player with a similar profile signs for $15 million or more, Toronto’s deal looks even sharper.
And if Gauthier lands a five-year contract, Anaheim could be paying premium money twice over. Knies will still get more expensive if he keeps trending up, but depending on the exact terms, he may remain well below Gauthier’s number for a long time.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Could Face One Tough Decision With Reilly Smith
The Maple Leafs are weighing a professional tryout for Reilly Smith, a veteran forward whose rsum still carries plenty of value for a team looking to deepen its options. With more than 575 points and approaching 1,000 NHL games, Smith would bring experience, versatility and another layer of depth to a Toronto forward group that is always under the microscope.
The catch is roster math. Toronto already has a full contract roster, so inviting Smith in on a PTO is the easy part compared with what comes next if the fit is right. Before any deal could become real, the Leafs would have to clear space, and that is where a seemingly straightforward veteran addition can turn into a tougher decision than it first appears. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Prospects Have A Real Chance To Shake Up Camp
The NHL Prospect Showcase on Sept. 12-13 will give a group of Maple Leafs prospects an early chance to separate themselves before training camp opens. For players like Ben Danford and Tinus Luc Koblar, this is more than a tune-up, because the organization will be watching closely to see who looks ready for a longer look and who can start building a case for a depth role.
For a Toronto team that always has a few open questions at camp, these kinds of weekends can matter more than they seem. A strong showing does not guarantee anything, but it can shape who gets extra attention once the real battles begin and help nudge the early depth chart in one direction or another. [Read more 🡒]
Leafs Just Closed Off One Offseason Option Fans Wanted
The Maple Leafs have hit the NHLs 50-contract limit, a notable early-fall checkpoint that leaves the organization with no room to simply add another player without first making a corresponding move. As of Sept. 7, Toronto was the only team in the league sitting at that ceiling, and the recent addition of Brendan Brisson helped push the club into that fully booked position.
For a fan base still hoping for one more offseason swing, the timing matters because it likely shuts the door on any straightforward signing, including professional tryouts, unless the Leafs clear space through a trade or another roster move. Trades are still on the table, so the front office is not out of options, but the path to any further additions just got a lot narrower. [Read more 🡒]