Simon Benoit was supposed to be part of the return in a deal that sent Joseph Woll out of Toronto. Instead, he’s already fighting just to stay in the lineup in Philadelphia.
The Flyers acquired Benoit from the Maple Leafs this offseason in a package that also brought back Samuel Ersson and Emil Andrae. Woll was the headline name in the swap, and he’s expected to share the workload with Dan Vladar after what has been described as a pretty solid start with Philadelphia.
Ersson and Andrae, meanwhile, are no longer with Toronto after a pair of trades. Now the focus shifts to Benoit, and the early results have been rough.
After the Flyers were hammered 7-0 by the Pittsburgh Penguins and then dropped a 3-2 decision to the New Jersey Devils, Benoit is being taken out of the lineup. In his first two games, the 29-year-old posted no points, a minus-one rating, zero blocked shots and four hits in 15:59 of ice time.
That’s not exactly the kind of impact the Flyers were hoping for when they added a big, physical defender. The appeal was obvious: size, toughness and a player who can make life miserable around the crease. But the Flyers also need blue-liners who can defend cleanly, and that side of the equation hasn’t shown up yet.
Head coach Rick Tocchet is making adjustments, and there’s a reason Toronto was willing to move Benoit in the first place. The Leafs wanted more mobility and better footwork on the back end, and Benoit wasn’t part of that vision.
None of that means he can’t help a team. Benoit’s game is built around physicality, sacrifice and intimidation. What he isn’t, at least consistently, is a smooth-footed defender, and that can get exposed in a hurry.
He profiles more as a third-pairing option, which means the right partner matters. Putting him next to a 22-year-old David Jiricek may not be the answer, but a temporary switch with Cam York could make more sense. That would give Benoit a steadier transition partner in Jamie Drysdale and, at the same time, hand Jiricek a more dependable presence while he continues to develop.
There is still a path back for Benoit if Tocchet decides the Flyers need more bite and more edge on the ice. But that comes with a tradeoff: more physicality, yes, but also the risk of weakening the team defensively. That’s the balance Philadelphia now has to sort out.
In Other News...
Maple Leafs Fans May View Matthews And Nylander Very Differently Now
Alex DeBrincats new deal has added another data point to a salary-cap conversation that never really goes away in Toronto. Auston Matthews and William Nylander are already among the leagues highest-paid players, each sitting above the $10 million mark per season, and the comparison is hard to avoid when one of the NHLs top scorers sets a fresh benchmark.
Matthews still brings the kind of production that changes the entire frame of the discussion, with more than 400 career goals and the NHLs scoring title in 2023-24, while Nylander followed with a career-best 98 points in the same season. Even so, the next round of contract talk is only going to get louder as Matthews moves toward his next eligible extension, and the range being floated for that future deal will only sharpen how fans judge the value of Torontos stars now. [Read more 🡒]
Flyers Fans Have A Reason To Watch Torontos Defensive Search
Chris Tanevs move to injured reserve has put Toronto in a familiar spot, searching for help on the blue line without much clarity on when the veteran defender might be back. With the defense stretched thinner, the Maple Leafs have begun to look around the market for outside answers, a process that is already drawing attention beyond Toronto because any move they make could ripple through the rest of the Atlantic Division.
The early chatter has centered on experienced, defense-first options, and the idea is simple enough: Toronto needs stability, and it needs it soon. Reports and speculation from league sources have linked the Leafs to possible trade talks as they try to shore up a group missing one of its more dependable pieces, leaving the conversation open-ended for now while the club weighs whether help is available at the right price. [Read more 🡒]
Maple Leafs Showed One Encouraging Sign In A Loss Fans Know Too Well
The Maple Leafs left Utah with the same familiar sting, a 5-4 loss to the Mammoth in the final game of their three-game road trip, but there was at least one part of the night that looked different from some of Torontos more frustrating recent finishes. Auston Matthews, Jack Roslovic, John Tavares, and Gavin McKenna all found the net, and the Leafs kept pressing through a game that featured defensive breakdowns and plenty of penalty-kill work.
Toronto never quit on the result, even after falling into a deep hole, and that late push was the kind of response teams point to when they are trying to build something sturdier. Anthony Stolarz made 23 saves on 28 shots, and while the loss still counts the same in the standings, the way the Leafs kept chasing the game after the damage had been done gave the night a little more substance than the final score suggests. [Read more 🡒]