If the College Football Playoff committee was going to carry last week’s logic forward, Alabama should have been in trouble. Instead, the Crimson Tide got the kind of treatment that makes the whole exercise look less like a ranking and more like a protection racket.
Last week, Indiana got hammered in the CFP Top 25 after not playing, tumbling from No. 4 to No. 9 because the Big Ten teams it had beaten kept losing. This week, Alabama watched its résumé take hit after hit and somehow stayed parked at No. 3.
Kentucky, the Tide’s shakiest signature win, lost its second straight game, falling at home to Florida. South Carolina got blown out on the road by 4-6 Arkansas.
Mississippi State dropped its sixth in a row. Texas A&M lost at home to Tennessee.
LSU lost at home to Texas. In other words, every SEC team Alabama has beaten lost this week.
And yet the committee didn’t budge.
Chair Hunter Yurachek said Alabama’s strength of schedule and strength of record were not hurt by that collective collapse. He also pointed to the Tide’s win over Vanderbilt, the SEC’s co-last-place team.
“We’ve seen throughout this college football season after a big win like Alabama had at LSU, a team will let down and lose those games,” Yurachek said, glossing over the fact that LSU is 6-4 and now unranked. “Credit to Alabama not paying their best in Nashville and finding a way to win.”
That line would have landed differently if the committee had applied the same standard to Indiana. Instead, Alabama keeps cruising while other teams get punished for the same kind of résumé math.
The Tide’s path looks even cleaner after Saturday’s blowout of Chattanooga, a game against an FCS opponent that won’t do much damage to Bama’s metrics. From here, all Alabama needs is a win over middling Auburn on Nov. 28 to lock up a CFP berth, maybe a top-four seed, and at worst a home playoff opener.
Even an SEC championship loss to Georgia might not matter much. The committee already showed last year that a three-touchdown loss in Atlanta didn’t come with a real penalty.
That’s part of why Texas sits at No. 5 despite having the same number of losses as Alabama and better wins on paper, and why Tennessee slid to No. 9 after a 15-point road win even though it beat Alabama by 16 points in a second-half mismatch.
The move that pushed Tennessee down came from Indiana, which is 9-1 and jumped ahead after beating No. 17 USC by two touchdowns.
Yurachek shifted away from the strength-of-schedule and strength-of-record language that was used to justify Alabama’s place when discussing the Hoosiers, instead saying their improved offense helped them rise. The criteria, at least from the outside, looks anything but consistent.
The committee’s own rankings are also helping create the very “quality wins” it keeps citing. South Carolina is No. 21 despite a 28-point loss to a team with a losing record.
Oklahoma is No. 22 after a loss to unranked, 5-5 Michigan. Florida checks in at No. 24, with every loss by at least 16 points.
Mississippi is No. 25, even though it has dropped three of its last four and is leaning on a Sept. 6 win over Louisville to keep its case afloat.
“If you beat a team that’s ranked in our Top 25, that’s significant for us,” Yurachek said.
That’s the loop. The committee ranks the teams, then treats those rankings as proof of value. It’s a self-feeding machine, and the SEC benefits most from it, with eight teams in the Top 25.
Meanwhile, several 6-4 Big Ten teams - Wisconsin, Illinois, Penn State, Northwestern, Washington and Nebraska - are outside the rankings, which drags down the value of wins by Indiana, Iowa, Oregon and Ohio State. Part of that problem belongs to the Big Ten itself.
Five of its teams - Indiana, Nebraska, Penn State, Washington and USC - did not play a power-conference opponent outside league play. The SEC, by contrast, has moved to a nine-game conference schedule, and the committee is clearly paying attention to that even though none of those SEC teams has actually played the ninth league game yet.
So yes, the committee’s top four SEC teams are in good shape. But Alabama remains the most obvious example of the standard bending in one direction.
In Other News...
Tennessee Suddenly Has A Jalen Haralson Problem To Monitor
Tennessee will have to get through its next game without Jalen Haralson, as the sophomore guard is set to miss the matchup with Coastal Carolina because of a right knee injury. His status is day-to-day, and Tennessee Athletics will continue to evaluate him, which gives the Volunteers a small but real health concern as they try to keep their rotation steady early in the season.
Haralsons absence also pauses a player who head coach Rick Barnes has pointed to as still developing and working through the usual challenges that come with that process. For Tennessee, the immediate question is less about one game than about how long it might take before Haralson is back in the mix and able to keep building momentum. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Brings A New Offensive Concern Into Tennessee Showdown
LSU heads into its showdown with Tennessee with a fresh wrinkle on offense, as wide receiver Jackson Harris is listed as questionable for the game. For a Tigers team trying to keep its College Football Playoff hopes on track, any uncertainty at receiver matters, especially in a matchup where every possession figures to carry extra weight.
The concern does not stop there, either, with Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons also listed as questionable for the Longhorns game against Arkansas. Between those two situations, the weekend carries a little more intrigue than usual for teams trying to protect their playoff positioning, and Tennessee will be watching closely to see how LSUs offensive plan takes shape. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessees Offense Is In Trouble And The Vols Just Sent A Message
Tennessees offense spent the opening stretch of the LSU game searching for any kind of rhythm, and the early returns were rough. The Vols opened with Faizon Brandon at quarterback, but possession after possession stalled as LSU controlled the first quarter with a pair of field goals to build a 6-0 lead.
As the game moved into the second quarter, Tennessee made a change under center and turned to George MacIntyre in hopes of jolting the offense. It was the kind of move that said plenty about how the night had gone so far, with the Vols still trying to find answers and LSU already dictating the tone. [Read more 🡒]
