The SF Giants are staring at another offseason of change, and the pitching staff looks like one of the likeliest places for a shakeup.
Buster Posey and manager Tony Vitello are not expected to go anywhere, but just about everyone else in the front office or on the coaching staff could be on the move. On the pitching side, that would not be a shock.
Justin Meccage is in his first season as a big league pitching coach, even if he brought plenty of experience from his time as an assistant elsewhere. Frank Anderson is also new to MLB after coming over from the University of Tennessee with Vitello, and Christian Wonders serves as the assistant pitching coach.
It would be unfair to pin the Giants’ entire pitching mess on the coaches. The front office deserves most of the blame for failing to properly address both the rotation and the bullpen. Still, the numbers are ugly: the Giants have issued 487 walks this season, tied for sixth-most in MLB, and that does not reflect well on the group guiding the pitchers.
When a team is headed for a 100-loss season, change usually follows. The Giants last had a season this rough in 2017, and after that year they reassigned longtime pitching coach Dave Righetti. So it would not be surprising if Meccage is out as well.
If that happens, the Giants need to stay far away from the idea of replacing him with Mike Maddux, who was recently fired by the Los Angeles Angels. That move may have come to your attention through a very funny hot mic moment from Duane Kuiper.
Maddux was reportedly dismissed because he was unwilling to fully embrace or use technology and analytics. Since then, the Angels have posted the best ERA of any MLB team, though they have not exactly been tested by the toughest competition since the change.
Even with that in mind, the Giants may be tempted. Maddux was Bruce Bochy’s pitching coach from 2023 to 2025 when Bochy managed the Texas Rangers, so there is obvious familiarity there. Bochy will always be a legend to Giants fans, but he also helped push the Giants toward Tyler Mahle, and that signing was ill-advised, to put it charitably.
The bigger issue is that a full retreat to the past may not be the answer. Posey’s arrival after Farhan Zaidi was fired felt like a rejection of Zaidi’s analytics-heavy approach. That shift was not flawless, but it did signal a desire to move in a different direction.
The Giants still need a modern, balanced approach. Old-school voices absolutely have value, and experience matters.
But any coaching change should point toward someone who understands today’s game, uses every tool available, and also knows analytics are not a cure-all. Some pitchers may need a different kind of hand, and the next pitching coach should be able to recognize that.
In Other News...
Giants Bullpen Picture Just Got More Complicated After New Injury Update
The Giants got a mixed injury update that touches both the bullpen and the broader roster picture, with left-handed reliever Matt Gage beginning a rehab assignment with the Sacramento River Cats and moving closer to a return. For a club trying to patch together reliable innings down the stretch, any sign that a bullpen arm is nearing availability matters, especially when the relief group is already being managed carefully.
Marcelo Mayer is still on the shelf with a bone bruise and is resting for now, while Joel Peguero has been shut down for the season because of a hamstring injury. It leaves San Francisco with one more moving part to monitor in a bullpen that has not had the luxury of staying stable, and the next update on Gage will be worth watching as the Giants sort out their late-season depth. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Roster Shakeup Leaves Fans Debating Two Tough Decisions
The Giants spent the lead-up to their game against the Reds reshuffling the roster in a way that made the day feel less like a routine transaction log and more like a snapshot of where things stand. Bryce Eldridge was placed on the bereavement list, while Willy Adames, Victor Bericoto and JT Brubaker all landed on the injured list, forcing the club to turn quickly to depth and versatility as it tried to keep the active roster moving.
Matt Wilkinson was sent to Triple-A Sacramento, and five players were brought up in response: Nate Furman, Grant McCray, Anthony Molina, Ryan Walker and Shay Whitcomb. The volume of changes underscores how much the Giants are juggling right now, with injuries and performance considerations both shaping the decisions and leaving plenty for fans to debate as the roster settles in for the next stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Injuries Just Created A Bigger Roster Test Than Fans Wanted
The Giants already thin margin for error took another hit in a recent game when shortstop Willy Adames and outfielder Victor Bericoto both had to leave with injuries. Adames exited after a slide with an elbow issue, and he had already been managing a back injury, while Bericoto came out with a knee injury. For a club trying to keep its roster balanced day to day, losing two position players at once is the kind of complication that can force a quick reset.
San Francisco now has to decide how cautious to be, and the most practical path may be the injured list for both players. If that happens, the Giants would have room to look toward Triple-A Sacramento for help, with Bo Davidson and Nate Furman mentioned as possible call-ups to patch the gaps. It is the sort of roster test that can ripple beyond one game, especially when injuries hit both the infield and outfield at the same time. [Read more 🡒]