The Padres have pushed into sole possession of the second NL Wild Card spot, but the pitching picture behind that standing is getting messy at exactly the wrong time. Jason Adam is close, Joe Musgrove is almost out of time, and Casey Mize is turning what looked like a useful addition into a real October dilemma.
Adam’s rehab line has been brutal: nine earned runs in one-third of an inning over two straight appearances. He gave up five runs without recording an out Wednesday, then allowed four more while getting one out Thursday.
That kind of stat line jumps off the page, but it does not tell the whole story. Even with the rough results in the Pacific Coast League, Adam says he feels good physically, and his velocity has stayed in its usual range.
That matters after a shoulder strain knocked him out in early July. He opened the assignment with a perfect inning on Sept. 13, and before the injury he had a 2.51 ERA in 36 appearances for San Diego.
One clean outing would go a long way toward calming things down. If the shoulder responds well, the Padres will likely bring him back, and they could use another reliever they trust while trying to manage workloads.
Musgrove’s situation is far less flexible. He threw five innings of one-run ball for Triple-A El Paso on Aug. 27, but the recovery process between high-intensity outings has not moved fast enough. The Padres had talked about shorter starts and even a temporary bullpen role, but there are only seven regular-season games left after Saturday.
At this point, the calendar is doing the talking. It is difficult to see Musgrove making the postseason roster unless he suddenly checks every box, from pitching effectiveness to recovery on a usable schedule.
He has not done that. If he somehow clears all of those hurdles, San Diego can revisit the idea.
Otherwise, the smarter play is to stop trying to solve a 2026 problem with Musgrove’s surgically repaired elbow and preserve his chance to contribute in 2027.
Mize is the one who is healthy, and that may be the problem. Before Saturday’s start, he called his move from Detroit “choppy.”
Then he walked five Marlins, threw only 39 of 74 pitches for strikes and gave up five earned runs in three innings. Choppy may have been too generous.
Across nine starts with the Padres, Mize owns a 6.64 ERA in 40 2/3 innings. He came over from Detroit with a 2.70 ERA and the expectation that he would help steady a rotation San Diego had been trying to patch together for months. Instead, he has added another layer of uncertainty.
The Padres still pulled out a 7-6 walk-off win Saturday, with Ethan Salas delivering the finish, but that did not erase the seven innings the bullpen had to cover. Mize may get another turn, but an October rotation spot should no longer be treated like a given. He has not pitched his way into the club’s top four starters, and if he makes the postseason roster, a multi-inning relief role is starting to make more sense than giving him a playoff start.
In Other News...
Padres Just Made A Rotation Move For Their Biggest Moment
With the Padres closing in on a National League Wild Card berth, Craig Stammen has adjusted the rotation to keep Michael King lined up for the clubs biggest swing of the season. King was moved to pitch on Tuesday, a move that leaves him available to start either the final game of the regular season or, if needed, the playoff opener against the Arizona Diamondbacks.
The timing fits the moment San Diego is in, with the Padres tied with the Chicago Cubs for the top Wild Card position and every day now carrying added weight. King has been one of the teams steadiest arms this season, and the decision to hold him back underlines how much the Padres are thinking about the immediate future, not just the next turn through the rotation. [Read more 🡒]
Joe Musgroves October Outlook Just Got More Concerning For Padres Fans
Joe Musgroves path back to the Padres has been slower than anyone hoped, and with October approaching, the latest update only adds to the uncertainty. He has not faced hitters since his last minor league rehab outing on Aug. 27 and remains on the injured list while working back from the Tommy John surgery he had in October 2024.
Manager Craig Stammen said Musgrove is still playing catch and trying to make it back this season, but the comeback has clearly taken longer than expected. San Diego has already given him plenty of time to return, and the most realistic path, if he does get back, appears to be in a relief role rather than a spot in the rotation. [Read more 🡒]
Padres About To See A Very Different Dodgers Team
The next time the Padres line up against the Dodgers, the matchup figures to look a lot different than the one they have been preparing for in recent weeks. Los Angeles is getting healthier at a key point in the schedule, with Roki Sasaki expected back from the injured list this week in a relief role and Shohei Ohtani also nearing a return, potentially as soon as Wednesday.
Andy Pages is also expected to be reinstated before the upcoming series against San Diego, adding another regular to the Dodgers mix. One notable absence remains on the pitching side, with Blake Snell dealing with groin discomfort and ruled out for the Padres series, though he could be back for the following set against the Giants. [Read more 🡒]