Aaron Boone didn’t exactly leave the door open for Jazz Chisholm Jr. on Wednesday.
At New York’s end-of-season press conference, Boone was asked a follow-up about whether Chisholm Jr.’s June lollipop incident bothered him. The Yankees manager’s response made it plain that it still does.
“I answered that in real time. I think you know it bothered me.
So, yeah, it bothered me. You didn't hear my answer to that when that happened?
Yeah, and that was one of those things that I called out from this set that bothered me. I'm surprised you missed that.
I've also said up here that nothing's perfect, but I said as a whole we had a lot of the right ingredients. Doesn't mean we didn't have individual things pop up, or doesn't mean it's a perfect room by any means, and when those things do come up I try to address them,” Boone said.
That answer matters because it adds to the growing sense that Chisholm Jr.’s time in the Bronx is done. He entered 2026 with plenty of noise around him and talk to match, but the season didn’t go the way he needed it to.
Even with Aaron Judge mostly absent, this was the kind of year that could have locked him into pinstripes and set him up for a big payday. Instead, he came up short.
A strong finish was supposed to help change the conversation. Injury wiped out that chance, and the playoffs became his final shot to salvage the relationship.
He didn’t take it. After his throwing error in Game 2 of the ALDS, he doubled down instead of backing down, and the impression he left only got worse.
When Anthony Rizzo eviserated him after New York’s elimination, it reinforced the feeling that Chisholm Jr. wasn’t connecting with what the Yankees wanted from him. Boone’s comments only sharpened that reality. The manager, who has often gone to bat for his players, did not treat this as a harmless personality quirk or a minor misstep that could be brushed aside.
Boone has plenty of history defending his guys, sometimes long after the evidence says otherwise. In August, on the Talkin’ Yanks Podcast, he argued with Jomboy that Trent Grisham was still an above-average center fielder even as the numbers and the eye test told a different story. That tendency has fueled complaints from fans for a while.
This time, though, Boone sounded less like a protector and more like someone drawing a line. The phrase “we had a lot of the right ingredients” carries a lot of weight, because it also suggests there were ingredients that didn’t belong. Put that together with Judge’s public reaction and Boone’s own frustration, and the picture gets pretty clear.
Even with the offseason ahead, it’s hard to see Brian Cashman forcing a reunion after this. The manager’s stance, Judge’s response, and Chisholm Jr.’s 2026 season all point in the same direction: the Yankees and Jazz Chisholm Jr. are headed for a split.
In Other News...
Mets Could Have A Real Shot At These World Series Names
The Mets have spent plenty of time hunting for upgrades on the margins, and the latest look around the 2026 World Series participant pool suggests there could be a few names worth watching. Milwaukee and Tampa Bay are both operating under payroll pressure, which makes the Brewers and Rays the kind of teams that can be forced into difficult roster decisions if the right offer or contract opportunity comes along.
For New York, that opens the door to a handful of players who could fit different needs, from a more established bat to bullpen depth and rotation help. Yandy Diaz, Drew Rasmussen, Nick Martinez, Trevor Megill and JoJo Romero all come with varying levels of value and uncertainty, but the bigger point is clear: the Mets may have a real path to adding talent if either club has to move pieces or let the market do the work. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Suddenly Have A Real Ron Darling Question
Ron Darling has given the Mets a broadcasting storyline to watch heading into the offseason, even if it has nothing to do with the roster or the dugout. Darling said he is still undecided about returning to the booth next season, despite having two more years left on his deals with both TBS and SNY, and he described his approach as a year-to-year evaluation of his options.
For Mets fans who have come to expect Darling as part of the familiar broadcast rhythm, the uncertainty matters because it touches a voice that has long been part of the team's daily presence. Darling also weighed in on former Met Freddy Peralta's success with the Tampa Bay Rays, saying the organization helped restore Peralta to the form he already had rather than fundamentally changing him, a reminder of how closely he still follows the broader baseball landscape even as he weighs his own future. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Fans May Not Like David Stearns' First Base Plan
First base became an issue for the Mets in 2026 after Pete Alonso departed, and the position never quite settled down the way the club would have hoped. Jared Young surfaced as one of the more notable internal answers, even if his overall impact was limited, and that has only sharpened the question of how aggressively New York will try to fix the spot heading into 2027.
Chelsea Jane of SNY suggested the Mets may not make a major splash there, instead leaning on Young, Jorge Polanco and other in-house options. That would fit the way David Stearns has tended to operate, with a preference for shorter commitments and cost-conscious moves, but it is not the kind of approach that will thrill a fan base still looking for a more certain solution at first. [Read more 🡒]