The preseason is in the books, and the NFC South is heading toward Week 1 with a little clarity and a lot still to sort out. Some teams got real answers. Others mostly got reminders of what they still need.
Tampa Bay may have had the cleanest preseason of the bunch. QB Jalon Daniels looked like a long-term answer after Baker Mayfield, Reuben Bain Jr. flashed enough to make the Buccaneers feel good about the pick, and the club also locked up star DT Vita Vea with a contract extension.
That wasn’t all. Bain Jr.’s teammate Kieonte Scott turned in some strong moments too, and that could wind up mattering even more if he’s truly a usable CB.
Tampa Bay’s pass defense is arguably its biggest weakness, so any help there matters.
The Bucs also needed their rookies to deliver because this roster has dealt with injuries and turnover. Losing Mike Evans in the offseason was a major hit, and the team used the draft to bring in Ted Hurst as his “replacement.” Hurst didn’t put up any huge preseason numbers, but Bucs media is high on him.
Carolina’s preseason came with a much rougher backdrop. Nic Scourton, a standout rookie last year, tore his ACL, and rookie WR Chris Brazzell III also went down with a season-ending knee injury. Brazzell has plenty of upside thanks to his athleticism and size, but he was still in the developmental stage of his NFL career, so the injury could slow that growth and cost the Panthers the production they were hoping for this season.
Still, Carolina did get encouraging work from a pair of receivers. John Metchie III and Jimmy Horn Jr. both stood out in the preseason and made the roster. They’re still depth pieces, but Metchie III does have the benefit of having played with QB Bryce Young in college.
Atlanta is still waiting on a Week 1 quarterback decision, and the preseason didn’t exactly make that simple. Michael Penix Jr. is working his way back from the season-ending injury he suffered last year, but he may not be fully healthy, and pushing that would not make much sense.
Tua Tagovailoa also finished the preseason poorly, struggling against his former team, the Miami Dolphins. Jack Strand ended up being the quarterback who stood out most, and he made the roster along with Penix, Tua, and Cooper Rush.
The Falcons also kept only two running backs on their 53-man roster. With Bijan Robinson in the fold, there’s less pressure to stockpile depth there, though HC Kevin Stefanski knows firsthand how quickly RB injuries can pile up from his time in Cleveland.
New Orleans had the most uneven preseason of the division. It opened with a close loss, followed by a rough defeat, then closed with a strong win.
At points, the position battles looked flat and uninspiring, but the third game against the Dallas Cowboys helped lift the mood a bit heading into the season. Spencer Rattler won the backup QB job, Daniel Carlson won the kicker battle, and Kevin Austin Jr. initially grabbed the final WR spot before being released shortly after.
Even with those decisions settled, the Saints still have major questions at WR and TE. They need to add at least one player at each spot. Carrying only four wideouts, especially with the injury luck this team has had, and only three tight ends even though the plan is to use more TEs this season, doesn’t make much sense.
In Other News...
Saints Just Made A Roster Decision Fans May Not Like
The Saints made another quiet but meaningful roster move by reaching injury settlements with running back Devin Neal and edge rusher Michael Heldman, then placing both on waivers. It is the kind of decision that rarely grabs headlines on its own, but it matters for a team trying to manage the back end of its roster and keep as much flexibility as possible heading into the next stretch of the season.
Neal and Heldman had both flashed enough potential before getting hurt to make this a tricky call for New Orleans, which is part of why the move may not sit well with fans. The settlements allow each player to become a free agent while also giving the Saints some salary cap relief, and there is still a path for either one to return after the settlement period and a three-week wait. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Quarterback Future Just Became The NFC South's Biggest Debate
The NFC South hardly separated itself in 2025, with Carolina winning the division at 8-9 and a minus-69 point differential, and CBS Sports latest power rankings grouped all four teams in the same tier. For the Saints, that kind of landscape only sharpens the focus on quarterback, because in a division this flat, even a modest edge at the position can swing the race one way or another.
New Orleans enters the conversation with plenty still unsettled elsewhere on the roster, which is why the quarterback outlook looms so large. If the Saints can solve that spot, they have a real chance to climb in a division where no team has clearly separated itself, but if it remains a question mark, the path looks a lot murkier than a standings line might suggest. [Read more 🡒]
Taysom Hills Saints Exit Leaves One Big Question Unanswered
Taysom Hills departure from New Orleans closes a long, unusual chapter for the Saints, but it does not quite answer what comes next. After nine seasons with the organization, the do-it-all playmaker is on the open market, a rare free agent who has spent his career lining up all over the field and giving the offense a flexibility few players can match.
Hill has not signed with another team yet, and there is still no official retirement announcement, which leaves his status hanging in the balance. His age and distinctive style of play may be part of what makes the market tricky, and for now the Saints are left with a familiar problem for rivals to consider too: whether a player with Hills kind of value is simply waiting for the right fit, or whether his NFL future is already drifting into the unknown. [Read more 🡒]