The Giants don’t sound concerned about the biggest knock on J.J. McCarthy.
That issue followed him well before New York made him its quarterback answer, with a report months ago saying people inside Minnesota were uneasy about “McCarthy’s accuracy, his touch and his consistency.” The same story also noted that “The lack of touch coincides with McCarthy’s lack of precision as a passer in 2025,” while the Giants’ website pointed out that McCarthy “throws what the analytics say is one of the fastest fastballs from a quarterback in the NFL.”
But after McCarthy was named the Giants’ QB1, Malik Nabers made it clear he isn’t spending much time worrying about the velocity.
“Adjustment is just focusing on the ball, just watching the nose of the ball, timing your hands up and clenching the ball when it hits your hand,” Nabers explained. “It doesn't matter how fast the ball comes.
As long as you time it up right, you're able to catch the ball. So, that's all I've got to say about that.
I don't think it's really that hard to just catch any QB's throw. It's just timing up catching the ball.”
Nabers spoke to reporters about 24 hours after McCarthy got the nod, and the timing matters because the wideout and the rest of the Giants’ pass catchers haven’t had much run with the 2024 first-round pick. The team brought McCarthy in from Minnesota in late September, so this is still a new partnership.
Still, there was enough in McCarthy’s brief Giants cameo to give people something to work with. In a relief appearance against the New Orleans Saints on Oct. 18, he went 11-of-21 for 243 yards with a touchdown and an interception.
Now he gets the full-time job. McCarthy is set to start when the 3-2-1 Giants visit the 2-4 Houston Texans this Sunday, and DraftKings Sportsbook listed New York as a 10.5-point road underdog as of Friday morning.
Tight end Isaiah Likely sounded just as comfortable with the situation. He said he’s approaching McCarthy’s throws with one simple mindset.
“I feel like every pass, I have to catch it regardless of the speed of it,” Likely said. “I feel like that's something that the weather's changing a little bit.
You'll probably get to notice a little more when it gets cold. But right now, I feel like J.J.'s spinning with confidence.
I feel like any ball that's in my vicinity is catchable.”
Giants first-year head coach John Harbaugh said Wednesday that his “plan going forward” is for McCarthy to stay QB1 through at least Week 18. Likely didn’t seem bothered by that one bit.
“Great quarterback,” Likely added about McCarthy. “Somebody that is trying to learn, get after it.
Obviously, a smile on his face every time he's out there. Somebody that is obviously competitive.”
In Other News...
Vikings Could Catch A Break As Colts Injuries Start Looming
The Colts second injury report of the week gave Minnesota a little more to monitor heading into Sundays game at U.S. Bank Stadium. The reports, which track participation from Wednesday through Friday and note designations like IR-OUT and limited work, showed a handful of Indianapolis starters dealing with availability concerns as the weekend draws closer.
Sauce Gardner, Tyler Warren and Rigoberto Sanchez were among the Colts players who were not on the field Thursday, leaving their status worth watching as the week moves along. Indianapolis did have some players move in the right direction on the report, but with no final game designations out yet, the Vikings still have to wait for the last word before knowing exactly who theyll be facing. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings Fans May Have Blamed The Wrong Coach For Last Season
The frustration around last seasons finish still lingers in Minnesota, and it is easy to see why special teams keeps coming up in the discussion. A single kickoff return, along with a handful of other key moments across the year, fed the belief that the Vikings let a playoff spot slip through their hands. But when you zoom out from one play to the broader arc of the season, the blame gets harder to pin on any one coach or unit alone.
Matt Daniels has remained a central figure on that side of the ball, and his work has continued to matter for both special teams and player development. The bigger lesson for the Vikings is that the seasons disappointment was built from more than one breakdown, from quarterback play to coaching decisions to late-game execution, which is why the aftermath still feels unfinished. [Read more 🡒]
Justin Herbert Is Suddenly At Center Of A Chargers Debate
The quarterback market keeps a Minnesota angle in view, even after the Vikings made their own offseason choice by bringing in Kyler Murray and letting Sam Darnold walk. Justin Herbert has been productive across his first six seasons with the Chargers, and the questions around his future have only sharpened the intrigue for teams that are always watching from the edge of a franchise-altering move.
For the Vikings, any Herbert talk is less about immediate need than about the kind of rare opening that can reshape a contender in a hurry. Nothing official has been confirmed, and Los Angeles has given no clear answer on where it stands, but the uncertainty alone is enough to keep Minnesota in the conversation as long as Herbert's status remains unsettled. [Read more 🡒]