ESPN’s College GameDay opened the 2026 season Saturday morning in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, with LSU-Clemson taking center stage. But the desk also turned its attention to the Big 12 race, and the picks came in with a split decision.
Desmond Howard went with BYU, and he made it clear he likes what the Cougars bring to the table.
“Everyone loves Texas Tech; give me some Bear Bachmeier and BYU. Let’s go Cougs,” Howard said.
Nick Saban saw it differently. He framed the league as a two-team battle, but landed on Texas Tech after pointing to last year’s result between the two schools.
“I think it’s kind of a two-team race in that league. But BYU couldn’t beat Texas Tech last year; I don’t think they’re going to beat them this year. I’m taking Texas Tech,” said Nick Saban.
Howard fired back with a quick jab: “Bringing up old stuff.” That drew a laugh on set.
Saban’s point, though, came with an important wrinkle: BYU and Texas Tech do not play in the regular season this year. If those teams meet, it would come in the Big 12 Championship Game in Arlington.
Pat McAfee stayed close to home, backing West Virginia and leaning into both his head coach, Rich Rodriguez, and his alma mater.
Then celebrity guest picker Lainey Wilson made her choice, and it was BYU for a very different reason.
“Give me BYU because they’re the Cougars. And I’m a Cougar, and I married me a young man,” Wilson said.
Kirk Herbstreit wrapped up the picks by siding with Texas Tech.
“I’m going Texas Tech. Will Hammond.
Remember Sorsby, all the noise about that? Will Hammond’s healthy; I like Texas Tech.
They’re gonna have a big year.”
So when the dust settled on the desk, the Big 12 split looked like this: Desmond Howard and Lainey Wilson on BYU, Nick Saban and Kirk Herbstreit on Texas Tech, and Pat McAfee taking West Virginia.