Will Shane Steichen still be coaching the Colts in 2027?
That question is very much alive after the way Indianapolis has handled this season, and after the latest move in the quarterback room only sharpened it. The Colts have now abruptly released Daniel Jones, another jolt in a year that has already seen the roster and the coaching situation reshaped in dramatic fashion.
Owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon already made one major decision when she fired G.M. Chris Ballard one day after the Colts lost to the Titans in Week 6.
She kept Steichen in place then, and nearly five weeks later he is still on the sideline. With next Sunday’s game against the Giants followed by the bye, the timing would normally make an in-season coaching change easier to manage, since it would give an interim coach more time to settle in before the next game.
It would also give the Colts a head start on the search for a replacement. If ownership already expects a coach to be gone after the season, there’s little reason to wait before starting that process.
And yet the Colts haven’t exactly operated in a way that makes clean sense this year.
Once Ballard was gone, the team no longer had an experienced executive steering the trade strategy. Indianapolis quickly moved guard Quenton Nelson and defensive tackle DeForest Buckner.
It passed on offers for running back Jonathan Taylor and quarterback Daniel Jones. Then, on the day of the trade deadline, the Colts dealt two starting receivers - Keenan Allen and Josh Downs.
Steichen has been trying to manage all of that with a roster in constant motion. Now, with Jones gone, the challenge only gets tougher. Any judgment on Steichen should account for what happened before the Nelson and Buckner trades, because that stretch looked very different from the chaos that followed.
Before those moves, the Colts pushed the Chiefs to overtime in Kansas City. They beat the Texans.
They handled the Commanders in London. They took the Vikings to the limit in Minnesota.
Even with all that, the direction still seems to be pointing toward Steichen eventually being replaced. But the fact that he remains in the job now leaves the door open for him to stay longer than expected. The next general manager may be expected to work with him.
In the end, this is Irsay-Gordon’s call, and she’s been close enough to the action to form her own view. She’s on the sideline every week, seeing Steichen in his element rather than hearing the criticism from upstairs. She also hasn’t fired him yet.
There’s another wrinkle, too: a new coach might not be as comfortable with the owner’s presence in the bench area. Steichen, by contrast, is fine with it. And after the Colts made life harder for him by trading Nelson and Buckner, she may be even more inclined to give him another shot.
For now, the bigger point is simple: Steichen has lasted this long, and that means he could survive whatever comes next.
In Other News...
Colts Quarterback Mess Just Sparked A Bigger Debate About The Franchise
The Colts quarterback situation has already turned into a bigger organizational conversation, and Breiden Fehoko poured fuel on it with a public critique of owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon after Daniel Jones was released. Indianapolis had already taken a major swing by trading first-round picks and players for Sauce Gardner, then moved on from Jones after a rough season and a costly contract extension, leaving the roster churn and the front office decisions under a brighter spotlight than usual.
Shane Steichen said the release was made in the best interests of both sides, but the reaction around the move has gone well beyond the depth chart. Former Colt Stephon Gilmore stepped in to defend Irsay-Gordons football knowledge and leadership, underscoring how quickly a quarterback decision can turn into a referendum on how the franchise is being run. [Read more 🡒]
Shane Steichens Next Move May Come Faster Than Colts Fans Think
Shane Steichens first two seasons in Indianapolis have put him in a familiar spot for NFL coaches on the hot seat: respected for his offensive background, but still searching for the kind of team success that changes the conversation. Since arriving in 2023, he has not guided the Colts to the playoffs, and that reality has kept the focus on whether his work with the offense can outweigh the broader results around him.
Even so, Steichens name is unlikely to stay buried for long if the Colts do move on after this season. His track record with the Philadelphia Eagles still carries weight around the league, and the roster issues in Indianapolis have complicated any fair read on his tenure. The bigger question now is not whether his next opportunity will come, but how quickly another team might decide his offensive pedigree is worth betting on. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Ownership Debate Just Got More Uncomfortable For Carlie Irsay-Gordon
Carlie Irsay-Gordon has been a familiar sight on the Colts sideline for years, and not everyone has loved the optics of it. The principal owner and CEO has taken her share of criticism for being so close to the action on game days, even as she has said the hands-on approach is part of her effort to understand the game better and lead the franchise more effectively.
Mark Cuban recently stepped in to defend that style of ownership, arguing that being near the field can help an owner learn and make better decisions. His support adds a notable outside voice to a debate that has followed Irsay-Gordon for a while, and it only underscores how unusual, and uncomfortable for some, her sideline presence continues to be. [Read more 🡒]
