Colts Ownership Debate Just Got More Uncomfortable For Carlie Irsay-Gordon

Despite facing criticism for her sideline presence, Colts owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon finds support in Mark Cuban, who sees her approach as a beneficial learning tool for team leadership.

The Colts have become one of the NFL’s most watched messes this season, and not because of anything going right. They’re 3-8, Daniel Jones has been cut with seven games left, Jonathan Taylor is carrying a sputtering offense, Anthony Richardson Sr. is set to start for the first time this year, former GM Chris Ballard was fired a month ago, and several key players were dealt at the deadline.

In the middle of all that, Carlie Irsay-Gordon is drawing heat for something she’s done for years: staying on the sideline during games and taking in everything around her. The Colts principal owner has been getting criticized for that habit again, even as she continues to work the field with a headset and notebook, trying to learn the sport from the inside.

Mark Cuban thinks the backlash is missing the point.

The former Mavericks majority owner stepped in this week with a full-throated defense of Irsay-Gordon’s approach, explaining that he used to do the same thing in Dallas for the same reason. “I sat behind the bench for the same reason I sat in on sales and tech meetings.

So I could learn,” Cuban wrote on X. “Watching how people interacted.

How they responded to the good and bad and each other. Developing closer relationships.

Making them comfortable around me so they didn’t think I was a suit in an office and they could talk to me.

“I also got to hear what refs said to our coaches and players. And vice versa.

Taught me a lot as well. It’s all information to help me make better decisions.

The fact that no one else had done it, made it one of the many things I did that other teams didn’t.

“Good for her for being an owner that cares enough to not care what other people think.”

I sat behind the bench for the same reason I sat in on sales and tech meetings. So I could learn.

Watching how people interacted. How they responded to the good and bad and each other.

Developing closer relationships. Making them comfortable around me so they didn’t think I… https://t.co/l4Imyf1Bzb

Irsay-Gordon has already laid out her own reasoning. Last month, she told Front Office Sports Tonight that she’s trying to understand the team’s football operations as deeply as possible and believes that starts with asking questions and listening.

“I like to say on a good day I have like a fifth-grade reading level understanding of the game and just the basic concepts of what we’re trying to do, depending on the week and depending on our opponent and depending on the situation,” Irsay-Gordon, who became the Colts’ principal owner and CEO in June 2025, said.

“But I think, then, it just helps to understand and to ask questions because I think one of the things, in my opinion, like being a good leader is about listening, really to understand. And I think that’s what the best teams do.”

The criticism has only gotten louder as the Colts’ season has unraveled, especially after Jones’s midseason exit from Indy. But Irsay-Gordon’s sideline presence isn’t new, and neither is her willingness to keep doing it. She has long been a visible part of game day, studying the action up close and apparently not worrying much about what outsiders think.

Cuban’s point is simple: being close to the action helps an owner learn, build relationships, and make better decisions. He also noted that he didn’t catch the same level of “overstepping” criticism in Dallas despite spending plenty of time behind the bench. In his view, ownership should be hands-on, not distant.

And with the Colts continuing to lose, the videos of Irsay-Gordon pacing the sideline and taking notes are likely to keep circulating. But Cuban sees that behavior as a strength, not a flaw.

In Other News...

Colts Quarterback Mess Just Sparked A Bigger Debate About The Franchise

The Colts quarterback situation has already turned into a bigger organizational conversation, and Breiden Fehoko poured fuel on it with a public critique of owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon after Daniel Jones was released. Indianapolis had already taken a major swing by trading first-round picks and players for Sauce Gardner, then moved on from Jones after a rough season and a costly contract extension, leaving the roster churn and the front office decisions under a brighter spotlight than usual.

Shane Steichen said the release was made in the best interests of both sides, but the reaction around the move has gone well beyond the depth chart. Former Colt Stephon Gilmore stepped in to defend Irsay-Gordons football knowledge and leadership, underscoring how quickly a quarterback decision can turn into a referendum on how the franchise is being run. [Read more 🡒]

Shane Steichens Next Move May Come Faster Than Colts Fans Think

Shane Steichens first two seasons in Indianapolis have put him in a familiar spot for NFL coaches on the hot seat: respected for his offensive background, but still searching for the kind of team success that changes the conversation. Since arriving in 2023, he has not guided the Colts to the playoffs, and that reality has kept the focus on whether his work with the offense can outweigh the broader results around him.

Even so, Steichens name is unlikely to stay buried for long if the Colts do move on after this season. His track record with the Philadelphia Eagles still carries weight around the league, and the roster issues in Indianapolis have complicated any fair read on his tenure. The bigger question now is not whether his next opportunity will come, but how quickly another team might decide his offensive pedigree is worth betting on. [Read more 🡒]

Anthony Richardson Sideline Scene Fuels Bigger Colts Quarterback Debate

Anthony Richardsons afternoon against the Texans was over almost as soon as it began, with the Colts quarterback appearing for just three snaps before the conversation around Indianapolis shifted from the game itself to what comes next. Shane Steichen did not publicly break down Richardsons performance afterward, but he made clear the evaluation process would be broader than one player, saying the staff would review everything, including Daniel Joness play.

For a Colts team sitting at 3-8, the loss only sharpened the scrutiny on a quarterback situation that has been unsettled for much of the season. The timing matters, too, with New York up next on the schedule and every decision at the position now carrying extra weight as Indianapolis tries to steady a season that keeps raising more questions than answers. [Read more 🡒]