The Packers’ kicking situation has turned Trey Smack into one of the more uncomfortable conversations on the roster, and the numbers explain why. Through 10 games, the rookie has made just 71.4% of his field-goal attempts and has missed three extra points. That’s not the kind of production a team can lean on if it wants to chase a Super Bowl, win the division, or even stack up 10 total wins.
And yet, there’s at least some reason not to slam the door on him just yet.
History gives kickers a little more room to breathe than fans usually want to allow. Younghoe Koo is a good example.
In 2017, during a short rookie run with the Chargers, he made only three of six field-goal attempts and was released. He later found his way back into the league and became, overall, a highly dependable kicker.
His career mark now sits at 85.3% on field goals, and he has converted 95.9% of his extra-point tries.
The Packers don’t even have to look outside Brown County for a reminder that a rough stretch doesn’t have to define a kicker forever. Mason Crosby went through a slump in 2012, hitting only 63.6% of his field-goal attempts.
Green Bay kept him around. That wasn’t the same situation - it was his sixth season with the team - but it still led to 11 more seasons in Green Bay, and he finished his career at 81.3%.
None of that guarantees Smack will turn things around. It just shows that a shaky start doesn’t always become the whole story.
There’s also a reason the Packers may believe there’s something worth developing. Smack had a solid college résumé at Florida, where he made 82.8% of his field goals and went 10 of 13 from beyond 50 yards.
At the same time, there’s a line between patience and ignoring bad results. Green Bay has already lived through the headaches that came with Anders Carlson and Brayden Narveson. Smack needs a chance to answer back, but he can’t be treated like the job is his no matter what happens next.
He doesn’t have to be perfect from here. He does have to get more consistent, and soon. If he doesn’t, the Packers may be forced to make another hard call at kicker.
In Other News...
Packers Catch A Break As Rams Receiving Corps Takes Another Hit
The Rams passing game took another significant blow with Puka Nacua undergoing knee surgery and now expected to miss at least a couple of months, a timeline that likely ends his season. Nacua had already been placed on injured reserve after suffering multiple injuries in the Nov. 8 game, leaving Los Angeles to keep piecing together a receiving group that has been hit from several directions.
Sean McVay also said Davante Adams is not yet ready to return from injury, adding to the uncertainty around the Rams options at receiver. For Green Bay, it is the kind of update that matters in the broader NFC picture, because every setback for a key opponent changes the margin for error as the season moves deeper into the stretch run. [Read more 🡒]
Matthew Goldens Rise Is Becoming Crucial To The Packers Playoff Push
Matthew Goldens emergence has become one of the more important developments in Green Bays season. The second-year wideout has given the Packers a real downfield threat, piling up 58 receptions for 853 yards and five touchdowns while earning Breakout Player of the Year recognition at the 2026 NFL Channel Midseason Awards. Even with a few drops mixed in, Golden has grown into a central piece of the passing attack and a steady complement to Christian Watson.
For a Packers team sitting at 6-4 and trying to stay in the playoff race, that matters more by the week. With the running game and offensive line both creating challenges, Green Bay has leaned harder on its aerial attack to keep the offense moving, and Goldens rise has helped give it some needed balance and explosiveness. The question now is whether that momentum can hold as the schedule tightens and the stakes keep rising. [Read more 🡒]
Matt LaFleur Pumps The Brakes On Micah Parsons Hype
Micah Parsons is inching toward a possible season debut in Week 12 against the Los Angeles Rams, but there is still work to do before anything is locked in. The Packers have reason to be encouraged by his recovery, yet Matt LaFleur is keeping the tone measured, aware that the last thing anyone wants is to get ahead of the process before Parsons is fully cleared.
For Green Bay, the bigger picture is that the defense has held up well enough without him, with other players stepping in and delivering solid stretches in his absence. That has given the Packers some breathing room, even as the anticipation around Parsons continues to build, and it explains why LaFleur is resisting the urge to fan the flames until the return is actually official. [Read more 🡒]
