Joe Sakic is back in the chair in Colorado, and the move that could end up defining this second run is staring him right in the face: Cale Makar’s next contract.
Sakic already has one signature megadeal on his résumé from this Avalanche era. Nathan MacKinnon’s eight-year extension in 2023, which briefly made him the NHL’s highest-paid player, was officially handled by Chris MacFarland, but Sakic was involved every step of the way.
Now the spotlight shifts to Makar, and this one feels even bigger.
The last time Colorado sat down with Makar on a contract was in 2021, when he was coming off his entry-level deal. Sakic locked him up on a six-year, $54 million contract, a move that has aged beautifully and stands as one of the best decisions of his first stint running the team.
But this negotiation won’t look anything like the last one.
That 2021 deal came during the COVID flat-cap era. Even then, Colorado handed Makar a major contract.
This time, the price tag is in a different universe. The next extension is expected to land in the 16-20 million AAV range, a number that brings a new level of complexity for both sides.
And that’s where Sakic’s challenge really begins.
The Avalanche want to stay relevant as their core gets older, but they also need room to build out the rest of the roster. Colorado can pay Makar at the top of the market, sure. The problem is what that kind of deal could do to the team’s cap flexibility when it comes time to fill in the pieces around him.
That leaves Sakic with very little room to miss.
If he can land another deal like the first Makar extension, it would only add to a legacy that already puts him among the NHL’s best executives. The hard part isn’t knowing what Makar deserves. It’s finding a way to make it all fit.
In Other News...
Avalanche May Have Found A Cheap Upside Bet With Something To Prove
Fabian Lysells path to Colorado gives the Avalanche a low-risk look at a player who still has something to prove. After slipping down the Bruins depth chart, the young forward was dealt from Boston to Colorado following a 2024-25 season that included a brief NHL stint and then a productive year in the AHL with Providence, where he found enough offense to keep his name in the conversation.
For the Avalanche, the appeal is obvious: Lysell brings upside without much cost, and he could eventually be a candidate for a bottom-six role if he continues to develop. For now, though, the likeliest route points to the Colorado Eagles, where he would get a chance to settle in, earn more trust and show whether the skill that once made him interesting can translate into a more permanent role. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Are All In Now And Fans Know The Catch
The Avalanche have spent the past few seasons making a clear choice: chase the Stanley Cup now, even if it means thinning out the future. By dealing draft picks and prospects to reinforce the roster, Colorado has leaned hard into the present tense, and that win-now approach has left the organization with a much lighter pipeline than most of its peers.
Corey Pronmans latest under-23 rankings for The Athletic put a sharper edge on that reality, with Colorado landing last in the league. For fans, the appeal is obvious because the team is built to contend right now, but the catch is just as plain. When this championship window eventually starts to close, the Avalanche may have to navigate the kind of retool that comes without much young talent already waiting in the system. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Face A Bigger Threat Than Their Current Title Chase
The Avalanche are still operating with the urgency of a team built to win now, with Nathan MacKinnon, Cale Makar and Gabriel Landeskog fronting a roster that can chase another championship. But for a franchise that has spent years pushing its chips to the center of the table, the long view has started to matter just as much. Colorado has leaned hard on trades and future picks to keep the window open, and the cost of staying in the race has left the organization with fewer easy answers when it comes to replenishing the pipeline.
That is where the next challenge begins for Joe Sakic. The Avalanche have not gotten enough immediate impact from recent draft classes, and several of those selections have yet to become meaningful pieces at the NHL level. With the 2027 first-round pick already moved and more prospects shipped out to help the present roster, Colorado has to do more than simply survive the title chase. It has to find a way to draft better, develop what it keeps and make sure the next competitive core does not arrive after this one has already passed. [Read more 🡒]