The Cincinnati Reds passed on a move that could have changed the shape of their roster, and now Tyler Stephenson looks even more important to their future.
With catcher demand said to be high at this year’s trade deadline, Cincinnati decided on Monday to keep Stephenson rather than deal him before he reaches free agency after the season. Reds president of baseball operations Nick Krall said the club didn’t get an offer it liked before the deadline passed, but the decision still leaves the team in a tight spot.
Stephenson has put together a strong season after a sluggish start. He’s batting .256/.342/.417 with nine home runs, 32 RBI and a 108 OPS+. His .629 OPS over the first two months of the season was underwhelming, but since June 1 he has climbed to .913.
That’s why so many around the team are now pointing in the same direction: if the Reds didn’t move him, they need to keep him. Otherwise, Cincinnati risks getting nothing back if Stephenson walks in free agency.
An extension has been discussed for years. Fans were already pushing for one after Stephenson finished sixth in NL Rookie of the Year voting following the 2021 season.
Then came the season-ending injury in 2022, which limited him to 50 games. He didn’t fully rebound in 2023, when he hit .243/.317/.378, a step back from the .286/.366/.431 line he posted the year before.
Stephenson bounced back in 2024, and many expected that would finally spark serious talks. Instead, the Reds’ QB1 struggled in 2025.
If Cincinnati lets Stephenson go without an extension, the catching picture gets thin fast. Jose Trevino would be lined up as the primary catcher for the 2027 season, with journeyman minor leaguer Will Banfield as the only other backstop on the roster. Reds fans are also waiting on Alfredo Duno, but his Major League debut may not come until 2028 at the earliest.
That leaves the Reds with a clear path forward: work out a two- or three-year extension before the 2026 campaign ends. Stephenson is making $6.8 million this season, and a two-year deal with an average annual value around $10 million could be enough to get a deal done.
The money is there, too, with plenty coming off the books this offseason. The Reds chose to keep Tyler Stephenson. Now they need to follow through.
In Other News...
Reds Offensive Collapse Is Putting Pressure On More Than Nick Krall
Nick Krall has spent the past year and a half shaping the Reds roster, so the criticism around Cincinnatis offensive slump naturally lands on the front office. The lineup has been near the bottom of the league in most categories outside of home runs, and the overall look of the group has too often been one-dimensional, a sign that the problem goes beyond one bad week or one cold stretch.
Chris Valaika, hired in October 2024 to lead the hitting operation, has also come under scrutiny as several key players have slipped instead of taking the next step. The deeper concern for the Reds is that the declines are showing up in different places across the roster, which makes this feel less like a single-player issue and more like a broader test of how the organization develops and maintains offense. [Read more 🡒]
Ke'Bryan Hayes Is Giving Reds Fans One Reason To Keep Watching
KeBryan Hayes has not given the Reds much reason to celebrate at the plate this season, but there is still a reason to keep an eye on him. His offensive line has been far below what Cincinnati hoped for, and the production has been so thin that it has dragged down his overall value, but Statcast suggests the gap between what he has done and what he should have done has been wider than usual.
Hayes has also started making swing adjustments in recent weeks, and there have been signs of more power since late July. For a Reds lineup that could use any hint of upside, that matters, because if those changes continue to take hold, the numbers that have looked so out of sync might finally begin to move closer together. [Read more 🡒]
Reds May End Up Regretting One Deadline Gamble With JJ Bleday
The Reds took a cautious route at the trade deadline, choosing not to shop many of their controllable pieces and instead dealing only veterans Nathaniel Lowe and Caleb Ferguson for modest returns. That approach fit a front office trying to preserve long-term value, especially with young talent still lining up behind the current roster. JJ Bleday was part of that equation, a controllable outfielder whose early-season production made him look like the sort of player a club would be smart to keep.
But Bledays recent stretch has made that decision look a lot less secure. After a strong start, he has hit a long skid since June, and the concern for Cincinnati is straightforward: if the slump keeps dragging on, the trade value they hoped to protect could keep slipping with it. The Reds did not have to move him, but standing pat only works if the player in question keeps enough shine for the next decision to matter. [Read more 🡒]