The Cubs spent the 2026 trade deadline loading up on arms, with Kevin Gausman and Clay Holmes at the front of the line as Chicago tried to fortify its rotation. It didn’t carry over the way the team hoped in October, though, as the offense couldn’t keep up with the San Diego Padres.
Now the attention shifts to the offseason, and one familiar name is being pushed back onto the Cubs’ radar: David Peterson.
MLB insider Robert Murray of Fansided.com says Chicago should give real thought to bringing Peterson back after acquiring the former Mets left-hander in a trade this season. His view is clear: the Cubs should not write him off after one full year.
"The Cubs should strongly consider bringing him back, and there are folks across the league who believe that Peterson's best days are still ahead of him," Murray writes.
Murray stops short of saying the Cubs should choose Peterson over Holmes if Holmes opts out, which is what most people expect. But he does argue that Peterson belongs in the discussion as Chicago sorts through its pitching plans.
On the surface, Peterson’s 2026 line does not jump off the page. He finished with a 4.79 ERA overall, a number that could easily make a team pause.
Yet the split tells a much better story. In 80.1 innings with the Cubs, he posted a 3.70 ERA, a sharp improvement over the 6.09 ERA he had with the Mets before the trade.
The second half is where Peterson really found another gear. After the All-Star break, he worked 66 innings across 13 games, went 5-1, struck out 67 batters and turned in a 2.73 ERA with a 3.57 FIP.
Chicago’s defense played a major role in that turnaround, helping Peterson settle in after the move. The Cubs would not be asking him to be the ace of the staff, but he could fit nicely as a fifth or sixth starter, or even as a long reliever.
There’s also the money angle. Peterson may not come with a hefty price tag, since his rough stretch with the Mets could have dented his market.
With the Cubs needing multiple pitching options for 2027, Peterson looks like the kind of arm that makes practical sense. Murray’s message is simple: at the very least, Chicago should strongly consider a new deal.
In Other News...
Cubs Have A Bullpen Decision That Could Quietly Matter
The Cubs are set up to bring back much of the same bullpen group next season, which gives the front office a little continuity in a part of the roster that often turns over fast. Daniel Palencia, Phil Maton, Ryan Zeferjahn and Ryan Rolison are all expected to be back, giving Chicago a core it can reasonably build around as some free agents move on.
Jacob Webb is the name to watch in the rest of the discussion. The Cubs are likely to pick up his $2.5 million club option even after a rough finish, a sign they still see value in his ability to work in middle relief or handle setup innings if he rebounds. It is the kind of quiet bullpen choice that does not draw much attention in November, but can matter plenty once the games start counting again. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Face Another Winter Question As Key Insider Draws Interest
The Cubs are already navigating a winter of turnover, with Jared Banner moving on to become the Orioles' general manager and John Mallee surfacing in the Mets' search for a hitting coach. Now another familiar name from their organization is drawing outside interest, as Seattle reportedly weighs Cubs farm director Jason Kanzler for its managerial opening. It is the kind of back-office ripple that can matter as much as any on-field move, especially for an organization trying to keep its player development operation steady.
For Chicago, the timing only adds to the uncertainty. The Angels are also reshaping their front office and dugout, which can widen the market for candidates and create more movement around the league, while the Cubs continue to scout Japanese third baseman Teruaki Sato ahead of his expected posting this offseason. The question is whether there is a clean fit for him on the roster, but before that gets answered, the Cubs may have to sort through another winter issue closer to home: whether one of their important voices is staying put. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Fans Should Watch One AL Contender Closely This Winter
After a run to the 2025 World Series, the Blue Jays are heading into an offseason with a few obvious holes to patch, and the offensive side of the roster looks like the place where they may be most aggressive. Among the names already tied to Toronto are two familiar to Cubs fans, Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ, a reminder that a contender with financial muscle and urgency can quickly become part of the market for proven bats.
Torontos interest could make this winter more interesting for Chicago than it might seem at first glance. The Blue Jays need help at designated hitter and in the outfield, but the expected lockout and the kind of crowded free-agent bidding that comes with it could complicate their plans, leaving Cubs fans to watch whether the team that came so close to a title can actually turn that interest into a signing. [Read more 🡒]